The most provocative book of the year, I'd say, is Frederik deBoer's ALL IN YOUR HEAD.
It's a difficult read: challenging, excessive, discursive, sometimes offensive, but necessary. "Freddie," the "cool and rude" culture critic active on Substack, takes on the sad, sordid realities of severe mental illness, the failures of our mental healthcare system, and the ways that good intentions, ideological posturing, and the fear of saying the wrong thing can get in the way of actually helping those most in need. You can disagree with him. You can get angry with him. You can challenge his conclusions. But you can't ignore him. He has put a deeply unpopular and consequential conversation on the table. I hope millions read this book—not simply to agree or disagree, but to confront the issues, discuss them openly, and finally do something. With 50 pages of notes, 500 Kindle highlights, and many sleepless nights rereading this book, I invite you to click on the link below to see my ultra-condensed review:
ALL IN YOUR HEAD by Fredrik deBoer is a must-read
“We have to undo the kindhearted lies that have taken root in recent decades.”
Ok, I will just post the review here, so you don't have to go to LinkedIn to see it.
Mental illness is an urgent concern that nobody seems willing to address—not in campaign ads, not in midterms, not anywhere.
No candidate is saying, "I want to make it easier to involuntarily commit people," or "I want to spend billions on state psychiatric hospitals." We used to shuffle the "crazies" into mental wards, but terrible things happened there. Instead of reforming these institutions, we closed or downsized many of them, often without building adequate replacements. Half a century later, a shortage of medical specialists, inpatient facilities, and community-based services has left a heartbreaking number of people on city sidewalks, in jails, or in cramped, overused emergency rooms.
The subject did come up briefly in Iowa's final gubernatorial debate. Both candidates acknowledged the shortage of psychiatric beds and the need to do more for people with serious mental illness, although they disagreed on how to pay for it. The shortage of inpatient care is a public health crisis. Many who desperately need help aren't getting it. The sickest souls are unmentionable in many of the domains where mental healthcare is debated.
Fredrik deBoer tackles this issue, and more, in his latest book, All in Your Head: Illness as Identity, Trauma as Fashion, and the Desire to Be Disordered (Simon & Schuster, October 2026).
The title is misleading. The chapters are varied and sometimes excessive, reminding me of the emperor in Amadeus complaining Mozart's opera had "too many notes," so I will focus on what to me are the most important themes here.
Who Is Only Mildly "Mental," and Who Is in Dire Need of Help?
"Freddie," as he's known on Substack, writes with passion, conviction, and academic depth about subjects that everyone else seems unwilling to confront, much less discuss, much less do anything about.
The silence includes a taboo against acknowledging how bad mental illness actually can be. Freddie is here to tell us "how unpleasant, unstable, and dangerous the mental can be."Decent people trying to destigmatize mental illness have created "an equal and opposite myth, that of the blameless and harmless mentally ill patient." The latest school shooter should not be labeled psychotic, some insist, because "mental illness doesn't do that." Freddie opens this book with the sad story of Jessica Short because, as he explains, "it illustrates the profoundly misguided effort to support the mentally ill by lying about the severity of their problems." It hit so close to home for him, I can see why it occupies such a prominent place in this book.
A "serially violent mental patient" was allowed to wander away from his forensic ward and catch a bus into town. David Peterson stabbed nine-year-old Jessica Short in front of her mother, sister, and horrified onlookers.
"I'm a bleeding heart lefty who's opposed in principle to life imprisonment," Freddie writes, but he hopes Peterson, "who has proven himself repetitively violent and ready to kill, is never released. You are free to point out the tensions within that position as you'd like."Nothing but luck separated him from the killer's knife."
That chance was the only real governor of our universe came to occupy my mind as my own life got harder and harder," he explains.To fight unfair stigma, we deny that some of the mentally ill really are dangerous.
That's the uncomfortable distinction Freddie wants us to acknowledge. Most people with mental illness are not violent. Many are themselves vulnerable, victimized, and in need of help. But that doesn't mean nobody with a serious psychiatric illness can be dangerous, or that pretending otherwise helps anyone.
The Truly Mentally Ill
Freddie takes aim at the anti-psychiatry movement, which he calls a "right-wing, conspiratorial cult." He also argues that hippies and "crunchy" New Age idealists helped fuel distrust of the medical establishment and pharmaceutical companies.
His argument is that the people most in need of psychiatric care are often the people least able to demand it, explain their circumstances, or make themselves heard. Thousands die on the streets every year, he argues, not because their illnesses are untreatable but because the law demands that they consent to treatment they may be incapable of understanding they need. These are not conditions that can be managed through outpatient therapy, apps, wellness culture, or "holding space," he says. They require robust medical institutions staffed by professionals whose entire practice is built around the most severe forms of illness.
In too many cases, refusing treatment is not freedom; it is a symptom of the disease itself.
A society that refuses to intervene when illness destroys the very capacity for self-determination is not respecting freedom but abandoning people who cannot save themselves.
That's a powerful argument. It is also an argument that demands scrutiny. Who decides when someone is incapable of making that decision? What safeguards protect the person who is wrongfully confined? And how do we distinguish necessary treatment from the abuses that have made so many people distrust psychiatry?
The Dark Side of Psychiatry
Psychiatrist Thomas Szasz fought compulsory detention of the mentally ill and challenged the medical model of mental illness itself. Freddie comes down hard on Szasz, dedicating an entire chapter to the damage one doctor did to the reputation of psychiatry.
He makes a forceful case against Szasz's influence while acknowledging that the abuses Szasz opposed were real. Szasz may have been wrong about many things, but not about the dark side of his profession.
The former Soviet Union's detention of dissidents under the guise of psychiatric treatment is just one example of what caused widespread distrust of psychiatry, a field Freddie is working hard to defend. He acknowledges the horrors. He also argues that we've come a long way—that today's psychiatric professionals are more trustworthy and helpful.
The history of psychiatry is not something we can simply wave away. Nazi Germany's murder of institutionalized psychiatric patients is among its most horrifying chapters. Forced sterilization, institutional abuse, and the political misuse of psychiatric diagnoses have left a legacy that cannot be dismissed as ancient history.If psychiatry is necessary to care for people who cannot care for themselves, how do we make that care trustworthy when psychiatry itself has such a terrible history?
The anti-psychiatry movement isn't helping the mentally ill, Freddie argues. "It doesn't provide better treatment, more access to care, or more social support. It doesn't create housing, or jobs, or medication options with fewer side effects." Instead, he says, "It just creates a rhetorical shield for people who want to feel virtuous while doing nothing."That's Freddie's indictment. And it raises a question I can't ignore: How do we defend the need for psychiatric treatment without forgetting the people who have been harmed in its name?
Good Intentions, Gone Bad
Freddie also takes on some of psychiatry's most controversial treatments, including electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) and lobotomy.
Lobotomy is one of the great examples of the cruelty and ugliness that can arise from good intentions. The procedure was promoted as a way to make it possible for some severely ill patients to live outside institutions. That intention did not make the results any less devastating.
Freddie argues that lobotomy's popularity owed much to anti-psychiatry sentiment, not psychiatry itself. I find that argument important, although it deserves careful examination. Good intentions do not excuse disastrous outcomes, and the history of medicine is full of examples in which the desire to help was not enough to prevent harm."
The Work of Staying Sane Is Enervating, Degrading, and It Never Stops.
Nobody wants to be "committed." What do people do all day in these wards full of walls and "psychiatric beds"? We hope it isn't really like the haunting song "Memory Lane" by Elliott Smith:
I do what people say And lie in bed all day Absolutely horrified I hope you're satisfied
Freddie isn't writing about psychiatric treatment from a comfortable distance. He is open about living with bipolar disorder and having been involuntarily committed in 2002. He describes the "black, all-encompassing emptiness that left me motionless on the floor for hours, unable to move," avoiding friends, withdrawing further into himself, and unable to see that he was going insane.
A confrontation with his neighbor eventually landed him in the local emergency room, and from there in a hospital. He received a diagnosis of bipolar disorder and a list of psychiatrists and prescriptions for lithium and antipsychotics.
"I've been in treatment since August of 2017," he writes. "The side effects are hard. Taking the pills some days feels like pushing the mythical rock up the legendary hill. But I'm alive..."
And then this: "I have a thing in me that wants to kill me. I have wrestled it into a closet in my mind, and every day I lean against the closet door and try to keep it inside. Much of the time the animal is quiet, sedated by medications and therapy and my petty, stubborn desire to win a fight. But it is not dead or even asleep. It waits for me to relax, to once again decide that I'm fine and don't need the drugs, that I can rely on self control alone."
He describes the drugs he takes, for all their ugly side effects, as the difference between a life of permanent chaos and friendlessness and a stable, happy life.
His message is blunt:
"See your doctor. Take your meds. Stay in therapy."
That's his experience. He credits medication and counseling with helping him stay alive and live a more stable life. He isn't pretending that treatment is easy, or that the side effects are trivial.
Not everyone is helped by psychiatry. Some have been harmed by it. Some have been denied care. Some have been confined unnecessarily. Some have been left without care until a crisis occurs.
Those realities don't cancel one another out. They are part of the same difficult conversation.
"The Unpalatable Crazies"
While people who are "verbal, articulate, internet-connected, and often well educated" spread the message that diagnostic labels are cruel, Freddie argues, the floridly psychotic are not on Twitter. They are sleeping in shelters, cycling through jails, or locked in wards that psychiatry's critics have never set foot in.
His passion and anger resonate. He has skin in the game. Freddie describes his own psychosis without asking us to feel sorry for him. He's asking us to stop pretending that the most severely ill people don't exist.
"This book is my probably-doomed effort to insist that the unpalatable crazies not be erased, even in their ugliness," he writes on his blog. "Mental illness is a problem from hell. And that's why you shouldn't pretend. It's that hypocrisy that I can't stand, and that's why I wrote this book. And I hope that you'll buy it and read it. Even if you don't share my anger, maybe you can come to understand it, can come to see that I have earned it, not just that I feel it, but why."
As a culture critic who describes himself as "cool and rude," Freddie writes with fearless conviction, never soft-pedaling his opinions lest someone get angry.
I agree that he is one of Substack's most controversial writers. I don’t agree that rude is ever cool. No matter: Freddie yanks back the curtain, and I’m not looking away.
Go ahead. Get angry.
This is a man on a mission, not a wee small voice in the wilderness.
He got me to listen.
Thank you to Simon & Schuster and NetGalley for an ARC of this book. The views I share are my own.

