[GTA VI] Lucia Caminos: The Trouble With Wanting Everything and Knowing Better
I have a feeling Lucia Caminos is going to be one of those characters people spend an unreasonable amount of time arguing about. And perhaps that's a good thing. I don't find her particularly interesting because she's a woman in a franchise that has spent most of its existence putting men at the center of its criminal fantasies. That's an interesting detail, of course, but it isn't a personality. What catches my attention is something considerably less comfortable: Lucia seems to have a talent for getting herself into trouble and an even greater talent for finding reasons to do it again. Her story begins with a prison release, which is hardly the most promising introduction to a woman supposedly looking for a fresh start. She talks about wanting something better, about making different choices, about getting her life together. Fine. We've all heard some version of that speech. The interesting part is what happens when she gets the opportunity to put those intentions into practice. Lucia doesn't seem particularly good at resisting temptation, especially when the temptation comes dressed as money, excitement or the possibility of getting ahead. She knows the world she's dealing with. She isn't some naive woman who accidentally wandered into a criminal enterprise. She has experience, ambition and a rather questionable relationship with self-preservation. And I like that about her as a fictional character. Not because I admire her decisions, but because she doesn't appear to need our admiration to be interesting. I would much rather spend time with a character whose contradictions are genuinely uncomfortable than with another carefully manufactured protagonist who has a convenient moral explanation for everything she does.
Jason is where things get considerably more interesting. I've been thinking about their relationship because I don't see it as a simple case of Lucia being the dominant personality and Jason being the man who follows her around. That's too easy. She seems to have more initiative, more appetite for risk and a greater willingness to turn an idea into a bad decision before anyone has had enough time to think about it. Jason appears more hesitant, but hesitation isn't innocence. He knows perfectly well that some of their choices are terrible ideas, and yet he keeps participating. That's the part I find fascinating. Lucia pushes, Jason follows, things go wrong, and somehow the two of them find a reason to do it all over again. It's almost funny, except that there's something rather recognizable about the arrangement. We all know people who bring out the worst in one another while insisting that their relationship is built on unconditional support. Sometimes affection becomes an excuse for avoiding the obvious. You don't want to disappoint the other person, you don't want to be the one who walks away, and before you know it you're defending decisions you would have criticized if somebody else had made them. Lucia and Jason seem to operate somewhere around that territory. I don't think she needs to be portrayed as a manipulator, nor do I think he needs to be reduced to a helpless accomplice. They both have agency. They both make choices. And there's a good chance that each of them finds something in the other that makes their worst instincts easier to indulge. That's a much more interesting foundation for a relationship than the familiar idea that two criminals fall in love and somehow become better people because of it.
Something else I want to see explored is the relationship between Lucia and the person controlling her. GTA has always played with that strange arrangement in which the player can commit absurd acts of violence, cause complete chaos and then return to an ordinary activity as if nothing happened. We understand the fiction. We know we're playing a game. But that doesn't mean we don't become attached to the people inside it. I can dislike a character's decisions and still want to see her succeed. I can think Jason is making a terrible mistake and still enjoy spending time with him. That's part of the pleasure of inhabiting fictional worlds: we don't need to approve of everything a character does to become invested in their existence. And I suspect Lucia will make that relationship particularly interesting because she doesn't seem like someone who will always wait for the player to decide what kind of person she is. Her personality, her relationship with Jason and her appetite for risk are already part of the attraction. The question is how much of that personality Rockstar will allow to remain uncomfortable once we're actually playing. I don't want a character who becomes morally acceptable simply because the audience is supposed to identify with her. I want to see her make mistakes, be selfish, be unreasonable and occasionally make me question why I'm helping her in the first place. That's much more interesting than giving players a protagonist whose every questionable action comes with an instruction manual explaining why they should feel sympathetic.
And then there's the political circus surrounding this game. Thirteen years have passed since GTA V, and the cultural environment into which GTA VI is arriving has become almost as absurd as the fictional America Rockstar likes to portray. Everything is political now, including things that would probably benefit from being left alone for five minutes. A Latina protagonist becomes a cultural statement before we've even had the chance to properly meet her. Some people will insist that Rockstar is pushing an agenda; others will celebrate Lucia as if her existence alone settles some enormous historical argument. I find both reactions rather exhausting. She's a fictional criminal in a video game, not a spokesperson appointed to represent every woman or every Latina. Let her be complicated. Let her be unpleasant. Let her make terrible decisions without turning every criticism of her into an attack on representation. And let Rockstar be irreverent without demanding that every joke arrive with a political certificate of approval. What makes this situation particularly interesting is that GTA has always depended on offending somebody. Its satire feeds on hypocrisy, consumerism, political vanity, celebrity culture and the ridiculous ways Americans understand themselves. But satire is a strange business when the audience has become so to interpret everything through its own political loyalties. I wonder how much of the final experience will be judged on its actual writing and how much will be filtered through expectations that have very little to do with the game itself. Thirteen years of waiting have created an enormous space for people to invent the game they want to see. Rockstar now has to deliver the game it actually made, and those aren't necessarily the same thing.
I don't know whether Lucia will become one of the great GTA characters. I don't even know whether Rockstar will make all the right decisions with her. But I am much more interested in her contradictions than in the historical significance of putting her in the protagonist's seat. I want to know what she wants when nobody is watching, how much of her relationship with Jason is genuine affection and how much is a shared inability to stay out of trouble. I want to see whether her ambition has any limits, whether she can recognize her own destructive tendencies and, more importantly, whether recognizing them would make the slightest difference. Because knowing better and doing better are two very different things. Lucia seems to understand the first part. I'm not convinced she's particularly interested in the second. And that's precisely why I want to spend time with her. I don't need another fictional criminal who secretly turns out to have a heart of gold, nor do I need Rockstar to make her the embodiment of some fashionable cultural argument. Give me a woman who knows she's making a mess of her life, who occasionally regrets it, who loves someone who might be just as bad for her as she is for him, and who keeps moving forward because stopping would mean having to think about everything she's done. There's a character in there worth exploring. I hope Rockstar has the nerve to let her be one.
Comments
No comments yet — be the first.



