Back Where You’ve Never Been (S04E08)
Airdate: 13 January 2012 Written by: David Fury & Graham Roland Directed by: Jeannot Szwarc Running Time: 44 minutes
One of the less discussed indignities of broadcast television is that a series’ schedule — and, by extension, its survival — is frequently decided by matters entirely outside the control of the people making it. A show can be meticulously plotted, superbly acted and handsomely mounted, and still find its rhythms broken by a football match, a political convention or a presidential funeral. When Dwight D. Eisenhower died in March 1969, the “trekkies” of America were obliged to wait two months before they could see the last episode of Star Trek: The Original Series, because NBC’s schedule collapsed under the weight of obituaries and rolling coverage. Something comparable, if less solemn, happened to Fringe. The mid-season finale of its fourth year, Back Where You’ve Never Been, was originally pencilled in for the autumn of 2011; instead, it was shoved back to January 2012 because Fox found itself airing an unexpectedly prolonged World Series. Few things illustrate more neatly how little say the creators of ambitious serialised drama actually have over the shape of their own work.
For the devoted audience, the frustration ran deeper than a rearranged calendar. Fringe was already a series notorious for walking with almost glacial deliberation whenever the general plot was concerned, and the fourth season had refined that slowness into something close to a house style. Having to wait additional months for matters to stir at all was a peculiar form of torture. The consolation, and it is a real one, is that in this instalment matters do stir — though in a manner that complicates the story rather than resolving it, which is precisely what a mid-season finale ought to do.
The episode unfolds in what has become known as the Yellowverse, the timeline in which Peter Bishop was never pulled from the ice by the Observer. He is, once again, attempting to return to the universe he calls home: the one in which he survived his Walter’s attempt to steal him from the other side. When he tries to talk his Walter into helping him reach the Machine, he is flatly refused, and so he is forced onto an alternate route — across the dimensional divide to the Redverse, to petition Walternate directly. He persuades Olivia and Lincoln Lee to help him cross using Walter’s old transportation device, which in this timeline has been dredged up from the bottom of Reiden Lake. Peter takes Lincoln along so that the man can impersonate his counterpart and thereby get Peter access to Walternate’s headquarters on Liberty Island. Olivia, for her part, has a second brief for Lincoln: he is also to establish whether Walternate is behind the fresh wave of shapeshifters invading their universe.
The device is assembled in the Orpheum theatre, with Olivia standing guard while the two men make the crossing. They are arrested almost immediately by Fringe Division, but during the transfer one of the agents, acting on somebody else’s orders, shoots his colleague dead and turns his weapon on the prisoners. Peter and Lincoln overpower him; Peter escapes into the city while Lincoln is taken by Fauxlivia and her Lincoln. Fauxlivia, sensing that his story might have some merit, talks her Lincoln into locking him in a closet. Peter, meanwhile, talks his way into his mother Elizabeth’s house and prevails upon her to arrange a meeting with Walternate — who reveals, with considerable smugness, that he already knows everything about Peter, having spied on the other side at length. Peter tells him that the Prime universe does not trust him because of the shapeshifters. Walternate’s response is to summon his version of Brandon Fayette and shock the man with a specialised device, revealing him to be a shapeshifter. He knew, he says, that the Redverse government had been infiltrated, and kept quiet to prevent panic. Walternate’s price for helping Peter get home is simple: Peter must return to the Prime universe and restore trust in him first.
Elsewhere, Fauxlivia and her Lincoln trace the source of the phone call that condemned the treacherous agent, and receive Broyles’s permission to investigate the locations involved. Broyles then makes a call of his own, which reveals him to be in league with the alternate David Robert Jones — a man apparently supervising the manufacture of the new shapeshifters. The episode closes in the theatre, where Olivia is suddenly confronted by September, bloodied by a bullet in the chest. He warns her that he has seen all possible futures, including the one in which she dies, and before she can help him or press him further, he vanishes.
There is something genuinely strange about the architecture of season four. It began without Peter at all, and his absence fuelled nearly everything that followed; now, at the midpoint, he has become the only true protagonist, the only figure holding any view of the larger picture and the only one with real motivation to go home and restore some general order to the affairs of all the universes. Yet the script by David Fury and Graham Roland is careful to suggest that the task will be far harder than he anticipates. The Redverse situation has grown complicated with the apparent arrival of a third force behind the shapeshifters — a force with its own agenda — while the Observers may have an agenda of their own, and September looks set to suffer the fate of his predecessor August for interfering.
These complications arrive in the form of a brilliant twist that, perhaps not entirely unexpectedly, restores to the series its most formidable villain: David Robert Jones, who was so famously and spectacularly disposed of in the season one finale. The existence of a parallel universe is a convenient pretext for resurrecting him without cheating, and it brings back the always capable Jared Harris, an actor who can make quiet menace feel like a physical weight in the room. Jeannot Szwarc directs the complicated material with a steady hand and salts it with welcome touches of dark humour — the finest being a small boy in a public lavatory who witnesses a shapeshifter in action and afterwards reports what his mother takes to be “inappropriate behaviour.” The action beats are brisk, and the final image is sinister and spectacular enough to linger.
So Fringe has begun to move again, and that alone makes this a markedly better instalment than the one preceding it. The trouble is that another paradigm-shifting cliffhanger practically guarantees a run of slow-moving episodes before any of it is properly resolved — the series’ oldest bad habit, dressed up as ambition. Even so, as a mid-season finale it does its job with confidence, and Harris’s return gives the back half of the season something it badly needed: a face worth being afraid of.
RATING: 7/10 (+++)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/ InLeo blog @drax.leo Substack https://draxster.substack.com
LeoDex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax 1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7 BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk8



