Novation (S04E05)
Airdate: 4 November 2011 Written by: J. R. Orci & Graham Roland Directed by: Paul Holahan Running Time: 43 minutes
Erasing a major character from existence is the sort of narrative gamble that broadcast drama takes perhaps once a decade, and Fringe took it at the close of its third season with a straight face: Peter Bishop not merely killed, but unwritten, his entire history dissolved from two universes and every memory in them. The audacity was real, and so was the risk. Yet any viewer with a passing familiarity with the conventions of the form could have predicted the shape of the reckoning, because a series does not dismantle a lead and leave him dismantled. Peter would be coming back. The only genuine question was how gracefully the show would manage it. Season 4 answered that question relatively early — and answered it by making everything considerably more awkward rather than less, which is at once the most interesting and the most frustrating thing about Novation.
The episode is set, as the season has been, in the timeline where Peter died as a boy. His erasure has rippled through not one but two universes, each of them now subtly wrong, each a degree or two out of alignment with the counterpart it no longer mirrors. What this instalment has to contend with is the arrival of the proper, adult Peter Bishop into a world of people who know him intimately and regard him as a stranger, and to its credit it does not pretend the situation is anything other than excruciating. He is installed in the Federal Building in Boston, held somewhere between prisoner and consultant, and permitted to earn a hearing by doing what only he can do: applying his knowledge of the other universe's methods to the Division's caseload.
That caseload begins with a double murder. Karen Truss (Loli Triolo) is found dead in her home, her skin gone translucent, her live-in boyfriend beside her. The killer is a shapeshifter named Nadine (Michelle Kruslec), and her true objective is Karen's former husband, Dr. Malcolm Truss (Arye Gross), once a Massive Dynamic researcher attached to a clandestine cloning programme William Bell quietly abandoned. Nadine traces him to Vermont and presents herself as a cancer patient in need of the serum his old work could produce, and Truss, entirely unaware that his ex-wife is dead, agrees to help.
Fringe Division works out that a shapeshifter is involved and that Truss, not Karen, was always the target. Peter, drawing on prior encounters with the species, identifies the signal emitted by Nadine's memory disc and gives the Bureau a location — Truss's own laboratory. There, when Nadine briefly loses control of her form and reverts to Karen's face, Truss grasps what she is and what she has done, and is coerced regardless into finishing the serum that will stabilise her. He completes it as the raid begins. Nadine escapes by briefly wearing a dead agent's shape, and later retrieves a Hermes 3000 typewriter from a locker at a Boston station to report success to the other side, receiving in reply instructions to await the arrival of more of her kind.
Meanwhile Walter circles the stranger claiming to be his son and refuses him. He will not accept the story and will not help, paralysed less by disbelief than by the accumulated guilt of the damage he has done to both worlds. Olivia, for her part, suffers another of the time distortions seeded in the previous episode.
None of this is innovative, and little of it is deep. What it is, is functional, and in a season this structurally precarious, functionality has value. The script by J. R. Orci and Graham Roland handles Peter's predicament in a manner that is at least honest: he arrives with no credit whatsoever and must win every inch of trust, from a team that has no reason to extend it and a father who cannot bear to look at him. The scenes in which he talks his way from cell to consultant, using nothing but expertise, are the episode's sturdiest writing.
The shapeshifter plot, similarly, is better than the season's usual freak-of-the-week standard, largely because it has a genuine emotional engine. Truss is a man handed a second shot at the great discovery of his life and a woman in his lab wearing his wife's face, and Arye Gross plays the mixture of professional rapture and dawning horror with real precision. Michelle Krusiec, as Nadine, is the more conspicuous turn — cold, fluent, faintly amused by her own deceptions — and the sequence in which she swaps shapes to slip through a closing net is neatly constructed. That the episode ends on another cliffhanger, complete with the typewriter, is predictable to the point of reflex; the device had already been used to signal cross-universe traffic, and by now it looks less like a motif than a crutch.
What the episode does contribute is confirmation of how Peter's absence bent this timeline. Olivia, it emerges, was raised alongside her sister Rachel in Nina Sharp's foster care after killing her stepfather and bolting from the Cortexiphan trials — a Nina who is now a fixture of Olivia's life rather than a distant benefactor. The detail is dropped in passing and lands harder than anything in the case.
Novation offers little that is new and nothing that is elegant. It is, however, a serviceable bridge, laying track for the complicated business ahead, and it restores a necessary friction to the centre of the show.
RATING: 6/10 (++)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/ InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo Substack https://draxster.substack.com
LeoDex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax 1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7 BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9



