scrobble.life
Movies & TV Shows

Television Review: One Night in October (Fringe, S4x02, 2011)

(source:tmdb.org)

One Night in October (S4E02)

Airdate: 30 September 2011

Written by: Alison Schapker & Monica Owusu-Breen

Directed by: Brad Anderson

Running Time: 43 minutes

Following the mind-bending brilliance of the Season 4 premiere, Fringe quickly falls into a familiar television pattern that has plagued countless series in the era of twenty-two-episode seasons. The showrunners initially managed to craft a narrative that felt fresh and expansive, but with One Night in October, they retreat into the comfort of a procedural storyline. This is a predictable move dictated by the high-volume schedules of broadcast television, where the initial creative spark is often extinguished by the need to fill prime-time slots with standalone episodes. While the scriptwriters do throw just enough breadcrumbs for those desperate to see the general plot continue and perhaps secure some kind of resolution to the larger mystery, the episode ultimately relies on the familiar mechanics of the genre rather than the innovation that defined the season opener.

The specifics of this procedural storyline are set in the Redverse, introducing us to a terrifying figure named John McClennan (John Pyper-Ferguson). He is depicted as a highly intelligent, prolific serial killer who has ended the lives of around twenty individuals using a bizarre and horrific method: he drills holes in their skulls and freezes their brains from the inside out. This gruesome modus operandi immediately signals that this is not just a run-of-the-mill murder case. The Redverse version of Fringe Division, facing an inability to decipher the killer's MO, reaches out to their Prime universe counterparts for assistance. The ingenious—and somewhat convenient—solution proposed is to recruit the Prime universe version of John McClennan. This Prime version is an accomplished academic, a forensic psychology professor who has a history of helping law enforcement with criminal profiling. Olivia approaches him with the enticing proposition that he could replicate the work, albeit under very specific conditions. Not willing to reveal the highly classified existence of parallel universes to a civilian, McClennan is sedated and, accompanied by Olivia, is transported via the Machine Room directly into the Redverse.

Once McClennan awakens, he is whisked away to the last known location of his Redverse doppelgänger, tasked with the delicate job of discovering the killer's motives and predicting his next moves. To maintain the illusion of normalcy, Fauxlivia, accompanied by her own Lincoln Lee, dresses as Olivia and oversees McClennan’s investigation. As he examines the crime scene, McClennan quickly deduces that the owner of the house was driven by jealousy of happy people. This insight leads him to reveal his own dark secret: as a child, he experienced homicidal urges and struggled with the same jealousy that drove his Redverse counterpart. The tension peaks when McClennan accidentally stumbles upon a photograph of Redverse McClennan’s father—a man who looks exactly like his own father. The realization hits him with the force of a physical blow; he knows something is profoundly wrong. This forces both Olivias to come clean, explaining the whole situation involving parallel universes and the existence of different versions of himself to a bewildered and frightened academic.

Predictably, McClennan correctly deduces that his Redverse doppelgänger will strike again, and he does so with alarming precision. The target is a woman, whom the killer intends to abduct and subject to the same treatment. He plans to extract the victim's happy memories, hoping to share in that joy for himself. Before he can complete the procedure, McClennan, despite being from a different universe, manages to track him down and confront him in a tense standoff. The two men engage in a recollection of their respective futures, eventually discovering the exact point of divergence between their lives. In the Redverse, John was caught by his father killing animals and savagely beaten, a trauma that left a lifetime of frustration and resentment festering within him. In stark contrast, the Prime John ran away from home and found a loving new home with a woman named Marjorie (Enid-Raye Adams). Marjorie cured him of his homicidal urges, offering him a life of peace and happiness. This revelation is the crux of the episode's emotional weight; the Redverse McClennan, now subject to the Prime version to extract the memories of Marjorie, essentially tries to steal the cure that Prime John possesses.

The climax sees Olivia and the alternative Fringe team managing to locate the barn where Redverse McClennan has set up his improvised lab. They manage to rescue both the kidnapped woman and Prime McClennan, though the procedure has already been carried out. The tragedy lies in the aftermath: Redverse McClennan now possesses the memories of Marjorie, but he is suddenly burdened by a conscience he cannot cope with. Overwhelmed by the horrors he has committed and the happiness he has stolen, he takes his own life. Prime McClennan is returned to his universe, his memories of the last few weeks erased. However, the cost is high; he also loses his memories of Marjorie, meaning that as a potential serial killer, he might have to remain under surveillance for the rest of his life. Yet, unlike the erasure of his recent events, he still remembers the specific words Marjorie said to him. This creates a poignant moment where Broyles wonders whether some people leave an indelible imprint on someone's soul, transcending simple brain chemistry.

The episode also concludes with a haunting visual of Walter, still living in isolation within his lab. He begins to hear voices, specifically demanding his lab, which he dismisses as mere hallucinations. This subtle nod to Peter's lingering presence reinforces the melancholic tone of the series.

While the script is admittedly weak and unoriginal, relying on the "nature vs. nurture" theme that has been extensively explored throughout the series—with the double character of Olivia serving as a notable example from the past season—it does manage to end on a somewhat sentimental and metaphysical note. The idea that the concept of a soul supersedes brain chemistry is a fascinating philosophical hook, even if the execution is a bit heavy-handed. However, the episode never bothers to explain the logistics of how Redverse McClennan managed to develop such complex memory-snatching technology and become a brilliant scientist, aside from lazily throwing his alleged 220 IQ into the exposition.

On the other hand, veteran character actor John Pyper-Ferguson deserves significant praise. He carries the entire episode on his shoulders, effectively balancing the two distinct personalities and physical demands of playing both versions of the killer. His performance grounds the episode in a reality that the script alone struggles to maintain.

Furthermore, the episode is set in what could now be described as Peter-less "Yellowverse," and it subtly points to this version of Olivia being fundamentally different. The narrative implies that in this timeline, she as a child actually killed her abusive stepfather, a detail that adds depth to her character and distinguishes her from the Prime Olivia we knew. This subtle alteration serves to remind the audience that while the universe may have been reset, the people within it are forever changed by the loss of what was erased.

Ultimately, One Night in October functions as a solid, by-the-numbers episode that, by its own admission, isn't that important in the grand scheme of things. It is a competent procedural that keeps the lights on while the writers figure out how to rebuild the world without Peter, but it lacks the unique spark that made the premiere so memorable.

RATING: 6/10 (++)

IMDb link

Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/ InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo Substack https://draxster.substack.com

LeoDex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax 1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e

BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7 BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9

Comments · 2

  • @susmi(47)· 9h

    The image that stayed with me is the two McClennans: the same man, the same gift, and one childhood of love is the whole difference between a professor who helps people and a man who cannot live with what he has become. John Pyper-Ferguson carrying both of them without ever sharing a scene is a lot to ask of an actor, and it made your point about the face doing the work land for me. I also liked how you tied the stolen memories back to Broyles and the question of whether a soul is only brain chemistry. Walter hearing voices in the background is the thread I am most curious about now.

  • @hivebuzz(74)· 15h

    Congratulations @drax! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain And have been rewarded with New badge(s)

    You received more than 600000 upvotes.
    Your next target is to reach 610000 upvotes.

    You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP