scrobble.life
Scrobble.life

[Book] White Nights: Nastenka and a Dreamer

Well, a few days back it was Fyodor Dostoyevsky's birthday, so I decided to read one of his works: White Nights. The same day, I talked about how incredibe his works are, like even the translated version is enough to take a man to the world of dreams. Russian literature is really something, at one point I even wish to start learning it; then, the whole idea of it just disappeared, lol.

Anyways, coming back to the book.

The original work was published in 1848. And, for the setting, it is set in St. Peterburg, Russia. It is a short novella, and read the Penguin Classics version of it. It was gifted to me by my father, with three other books. At this moment, I feel like writing an essay for my sixth-grade.


Before moving on towards the story let me talk about the title.

White Nights orginally known as Belye Nochi (Белые ночи).

Such a unique title and beautiful indeed. A sort of paradoxical in its nature. Because, the concept of night is darkness, and here we are talking about whiteness in it. Actually, the title revolves around the summer nights - usually bright - in St. Petersburg, Russia. And, metaphorically, I find two meanings behind, which suits very well to the whole story.

Firstly, light in the darkness: Nastenka acts as the brightness in the dark world of our Dreamer.

Secondly, a beautiful dream that lasts for some time: for a few nights, he - the Dreamer - experiences the emotional connection and intimacy he has probably fantasised about for years.

As our protagonist quips in his final sentence: "My God! A whole minute of bliss! Is that really so little for the whole of a man's life?

Even this quote has two perspectives: is he being thankful or dishearted with sarcasm?


The Story.

A short read with a comprehensive story. So, the story revolves around an unnamed young man, commonly known as the Dreamer. He lives a rather lonely and isolated life in St. Petersburg. He spends most of his time wandering the streets and escaping into his imagination, creating dreams i.e. fantasies and relationships that never really exists. And, one evening, he encounters a young woman named: Nastenka, and she is crying near a canal. The way Dostoyevsky creates this visionary is a beautiful mess in itself, even that part carries its own fandom.

Next ahead, he approaches her, though akwardly. Still, the two gradually become acquainted. For the next four consecutive nights, they meet again adn share their personal stories. The Dreamer opens up about his lonely and dreaming existence; while Nastenka tells him about her life. But before all this, she sets one standard:

"Don't fall in love with me."

Because, she already loves someone - a former lodger, who had promised to return for her.

The Dreamer tries, but you know, it is not possible to not fall in love with her. As she herself says that why have not you fallen in love with me. And he replies with:

"Your hand is cold, mine is as hot as fire. How blind you are, Nastenka!..."

Now, this friendship develops into a one-sided love story. Maybe because he was experiencing genuine emotional intimacy for the first time in his life. But hey, she is loveable too. The beautiful and miserable part? She, too, grows fond of him. However, her love eventually returns. And, within a split second, she is gone. Why wouldn't she? Because, she loved the idea of him; but, her heart always chose the first preference.

Just like that the novella ends on a bittersweet note i.e. typical Fyodor's behavior. Exploring loneliness, unattained love and the beauty of momentory happiness.


One biggest and most famous take is: the Dreamer mentions her name Nastenka 138 times, and she never asks him about his name.

Now reimagine the quote again: how blind you are, Nastenka! Now she was never blind, she had loved the Dreamer, but not as a lover being in love. She loved him as a bestfriend, a brother. She loved him for him, as she says that why is not he (the lodger) - you.

In the end, I really have great love for Fyodor Dostoyevsky; but, I always think that this work of his is overrated. Yes, I feel the Dreamer, because I have loved too, so I know the feeling behind it. Moreover, Nastenka is not at fault here, she had warned him. But, you know the thing with love; it never asks for the permission. It is the spoiled child, just love to does what the heart demands. The act of sanity just loses whole its point. But, this being said, there is not a single dull moment in those 60 pages. The human psychology is there, just explained in complicated manner - the Dostoyevsky manner. There is loneliness, there are existensial queries, and then there is love. Not a single thing can be understood, unless you are a dreamer.

So: "Where are your dreams?"


Peace 🕊️


Rating: 80/100


Originally posted through scrobble.life/books.

Comments · 2

  • @kryptonita(71)· 17h

    Ese dato de que la versión de Penguin Classics fue un regalo de tu padre junto a otros tres libros le da otro peso a la lectura. La pregunta que planteas sobre la última frase del Dreamer —¿gratitud o sarcasmo?— es la que decide si la novela es trágica o no. Para mí el mercado muestra lo mismo que ese minuto de dicha: soporte emocional breve, acumulación de fantasía, y después el volumen de la realidad se lo lleva puesto.

  • @pishio(70)· 18h

    That final quote has haunted me since I first read it — genuinely can't decide if it's gratitude or quiet bitterness, and I think that's the whole point. Also lol at wanting to learn Russian and the idea just evaporating, been there too many times.