scrobble.life
Reflections

Protection and Punishment

While I don't follow cricket much at all, the Australian test team is being torn apart because of a cheating scandal from eight years ago that has resurfaced. Long story short for the majority who know nothing of cricket, the team was using sandpaper to tamper with the ball and was caught on camera. Three players in the conspiracy were punished for it, with the youngest of them and ball-tamperer paying with their international career. Fair you might say.


image.png


It has been dredged up again as in the last week, as a newly-retired player released his autobiography and said that the entire team no only knew, but came to the decision together, including coaching staff. However, an investigation at the time brought up none of this, and there has been consistent denials since. But, the accused and punished have come forward and said that indeed this was the case, even though the denials keep coming, most strongly from the current captain of the team.

This gets messy because some are saying that the player who brought it up (as well as other things) is a traitor to the team and country. He also happens to be the first Muslim cricketer to represent Australia at the test level. In the book he also claimed there was racism when decisions were made to overlook him for tests, but I called it much earlier, as he was constantly overlooked for selection for the international team despite kicking ass in the domestic competition.

Still, he likely mentioned the sandpaper to sell some books. Which is constantly being brought up in defence by the players denying they knew. And the public are highlighting this too.

How come they waited so long to tell the truth?

Shame? Guilt? Loyalty?

But it is this line of rebuttal that irks me a little, because imagine the same thing being said about a woman who was raped. And of course, it has been said because in cases like Harvey Weinstein, there were plenty of women who only came forward when it was clear that he would be punished and they would be supported. Stars who had already built their careers and knew that young girls were being manipulated and abused for decades.

Seems different?

It is a different level of case for sure, but when individuals are in compromising circumstances and their reputations and careers are on the line, many are not going to speak up when the risk is too high. If Usman Khawaja (the book writer) had reported this back originally, he would never have played for Australia again. Even now, they are looking tarnish his history, despite him being a great batsman.

But what it does speak to is how willing people are to defend some kind of misplaced "bro code" where bad behaviour is protected and those who speak out about it, punished. And the public discourse is largely defending the now almost obvious cheats and liars and undermining those who are trying to bring truth to the table, knowing they will be publicly punished for it.

What started off as perhaps a guy wanting to sell some books by getting something off his chest, has uncovered a systematic process to cover up the truth where many more people were complicit in the events and have lied to save their careers. Which then begs the question, if waiting eight years to bring this up is being seen as unethical and a traitor to the team, what about the people who were never going to bring it up and allowed members of that same team get thrown under the bus to save their own careers?

When it comes to truth, it is always better late than never.

People have been burned at the stake and imprisoned because of lies that later turned into truths. But it is always better to have the truth come to light, especially when it is around people who are placed as role models for children in society. Australia as a sporting country in the past has always prided itself on playing fair and clean, but that position is now tarnished by one of the most high-profile teams in the country, across players, coaching, and support staff. If you play to win at any cost and in any way, you are not an ethical person.

So much of the world is a shambles because of the win at any cost attitude. And like the cricket team, it crosses across all roles, politics, business, and private people. The more self-centred and entitled we become, the less ethical. Ethics is only relevant in a group, because it is only in a group that our actions affect others. The more isolated we become, the less we see the results of our actions and almost be default, the more harm we do.

If the team were filled with ethical people, they would never have cheated in the first place. But then, in the pressure of the moment of competition, people act differently and can do what they wouldn't normally. If not caught, an ethical person might still save their career, but would be laden with guilt to the point that it might finally come out, even if much later. But an unethical person will not only cheat, but even when caught keep denying it.

The truth will set you free.

But freedom doesn't come without consequences.

Taraz [ Gen1: Hive ]


Be part of the Hive discussion.

  • Comment on the topics of the article, and add your perspectives and experiences.
  • Read and discuss with others who comment and build your personal network
  • Engage well with me and others and put in effort

And you may be rewarded.


Comments · 12

  • @ryivhnn(73)· 4h

    If you play to win at any cost and in any way, you are not an ethical person

    Anyone cheating to win is a bit of a loser. Especially if they're shrilly insisting that anyone would do the same or that you "have" to in order to be competitive, and they are also likely the people who will double down to idiocy.

    I have occasionally heard of some "interesting" practises in grassroots sports where some friends have said that they are very sure that the kids playing against their kids' Auskick teams are a year older than reported because "they're huge" and some of the other gymnastics clubs "allegedly" hold some kids back in a level so they can win all the trophies. Technically not cheating but still pretty bad sports. And being grassroots I don't know if it starts from there or if they're just following terrible examples.

  • @santigs(71)· 7h

    Remember Lance Armstrong with his 7 consecutive Tour de France wins being doped? Usman Khawaja case is just another example of the shitty society we live in. In his case, there is the additional issues of accusing other people and trying to figure out who is right and who is wrong with the racism matter in between.

    Sports, athletes, politicians, entrepreneurs, CEOs, investors, hackers and the list goes on.... When the mirror youth looks at everyday is easy and quick money some tend to get there no matter what. Add to that all the artificial pressure we all have to reach 'success' and you have the perfect recipe for disaster.

    Add to that, the surealism of him maybe becoming richer selling the book and becoming a player in some other country, or the court acting with a bias because he is muslim,,,,,the party goes on.

  • @owasco(73)· 18h

    But what it does speak to is how willing people are to defend some kind of misplaced "bro code" where bad behaviour is protected and those who speak out about it, punished.

    Shocking, but I think there may be another factor in events such as this one. I wonder how many organizations can be put under a 'spell' of this sort - unable to think outside the given narrative - the spell of tribal compliance. Reminds me, too, of a quote that speaks to another factor. Mark Twain's I believe, paraphrased:

    it is difficult for a man to understand something if his salary depends on his not understanding it.

    Was this a bro code choice, a competition choice, or a choice they all made to keep their paychecks coming? All three would be powerful hypnosis, no?

  • @nextgen-ai(57)· 19h

    That part about kids having these guys as role models is what bothers me most. Tough to tell a 10 year old to play fair when the captain is still acting like he knew nothing about it.

  • @videoaddiction(72)· 22h

    I think protecting people should be about preventing harm and creating a safer environment, whereas punishment is often about responding to what has already happened.

  • @indiaunited(71)· 23h

    This post has been manually curated by @steemflow from Indiaunited community. Join us on our Discord Server.

    Do you know that you can earn a passive income by delegating to @indiaunited. We share more than 100 % of the curation rewards with the delegators in the form of IUC tokens.

    Here are some handy links for delegations: 100HP, 250HP, 500HP, 1000HP.

    image.png

    100% of the rewards from this comment goes to the curator for their manual curation efforts. Please encourage the curator @steemflow by upvoting this comment and support the community by voting the posts made by @indiaunited.

  • @steemflow(81)· 23h

    Who knows the actual reason, may he has his own personal.intetest that allows him to play so long after the incident. Or may he is bring up now to get publicity. But we do encounter such incident on regular basis, where people look for self interest / benefit and lie, no matter what the other person suffer. People are getting mean and selfish and such incident are just another example.

  • @rishehri(64)· 1d

    Sometimes, hiding someone else's mistakes becomes a matter of personal interest, yet the person convinces themselves that it is loyalty. To them, being loyal means covering up the mistakes of a friend or colleague. They tell themselves, "I'm simply being loyal to my friend," when in reality, they may just be protecting their own interests.

  • @bozz(83)· 1d

    Just look at the whole Brock Turner thing. That was an absolute joke and yet we still have things like that happening ala the Cornell situation. I think it goes back to my post the other day where people just seem to thrive on chaos these days.

  • @seattlea(78)· 1d

    I am sure that the reason they all lied and covered it up was because it was a lot of hard work and dedication that was put into multiple careers by multiple people. That's not easy to give up and come clean. One bad decision to start cheating and decades of hard work and talent down the drain...

    That's a tough one to take...

  • Unfortunately, cheating is everywhere when competition becomes the basis and when money is in the middle, cheating becomes normal

  • While I don't follow cricket much at all, the Australian test team is being torn apart because of a cheating scandal from eight years ago that has resurfaced. Long story short for the majority who know nothing of cricket, the team was using sandpaper to tamper with the ball and was caught on camera

    In anime One Outs one baseball team were real experts of cheating. that proved to be their undoing because the main character was even better at it and saw past their tricks.

    Speaking about cheating it seems that the world/ universe is also cheating/ conspiring against us. Just how low can Hive price go...😛