scrobble.life
📖 1 reader← All reviews
Movie40

Other Mommy, this could have been a good horror movie. My Review

Review by @kapitanrosomak 🏆#257 🔥1 🎵6 🎬219 📺40 📚3 · 1d · of Other Mommy · 1 view

It could have been, but it was missing the one thing that matters most a well-written story.

The beginning is very Hitchcock-like. It starts with a huge emotional punch, with the director throwing a terrifying scene at us literally within the first few minutes of the movie. And I'm thinking to myself: this might finally work. This could actually be a bullseye. It's quite a bold approach, but maybe it'll pay off.

However, after an interesting opening, the movie falls into a rather confusing routine of slow-paced storytelling. After a terrifying scene, it's time to calm the audience down with something, but in this case, the film practically puts you to sleep, which unfortunately has a major impact on the overall experience.

The concept itself is very interesting, and if you enjoy video game horror or like listening to YouTube channels dedicated to creepypastas, you'll probably be happy with this one. The central idea revolves around a skinwalker (in the movie, it's a demon, blah blah blah, but the whole stealing-someone-else's-appearance concept feels straight out of a YouTube horror production).

And I have to say, it actually works really well when the main character suddenly changes her face or adjusts it because part of it has started to sag. That was genuinely well done. The beginning might even give you a little scare.

But here's the problem.

The movie seems to have a serious identity crisis. It doesn't really know what it wants to be, and that's where things start falling apart. The biggest problem is the inconsistency and lack of direction in the story. The main theme is simply too weak for a horror movie. It might work as a drama, but as a horror film, it comes across as rather unconvincing and disappointing.

The movie also takes a little inspiration from Evil Dead Rise, particularly when it comes to the bathtub scene. And well, while Evil Dead Rise absolutely nailed it and its bathtub scene was genuinely terrifying, here I was practically yawning. There was no tension, the music wasn't right, and the actress simply wasn't a good fit for the scene. (Yes, I'm nitpicking, but seriously, it's shocking how much potential was wasted with that bathtub scene.)

Unfortunately, the second half of the movie turns into something resembling a soap opera, with the main character going through her personal struggles and wondering whether her parents actually love her, blah blah blah, all mixed in with supposedly scary scenes that make you want to fall asleep. Normally, jumpscares work on me, and I usually appreciate a good one, but here I didn't jump even once. And that says quite a lot. The music choices certainly didn't help either.

But the worst is yet to come, because the finale is where everything really falls apart.

While the second half still had some potential to deliver a decent scene, something along the lines of the Ghostbusters catching a ghost for the first time (which was actually kind of funny), the ending is simply terrible. The whole concept and the message behind it are almost comically bad.

The final confrontation between the main character and the evil entity, as well as the way she defeats it, feels like something straight out of a cartoon such as Courage the Cowardly Dog.

Unfortunately, the finale completely ruins the entire story. And even the epilogue doesn't help, despite trying to wink at the audience and suggest that maybe the whole story unfolded in a completely different way.

(No, it didn't. The audience isn't that stupid.)

Unfortunately, this movie could have been a genuinely solid horror film, one that would scare you from the very first minutes. However, the director tried too hard to get creative, and instead of taking inspiration from the book in a way that would actually work on screen, they apparently took elements that might have worked perfectly well in the book but simply don't translate into a horror movie.

Because what's missing here is tension, and, most importantly, a properly written story. :)

Ratings:

First half: 7/10

Middle: 5/10

Finale: 2/10

Overall: 4/10

And that's a shame, because this could have been the first really interesting horror movie about a creature that steals other people's identities.

Rating: 40/100

Voted by
  • @ocdb
  • @ocd
  • @kubak
  • @meritocracy
  • @eds-vote
  • @roelandp
  • @solymi
  • @chireerocks
  • @eddie-earner
  • @kraken99
  • @ocd-witness
  • @dannewton
  • @eliel
  • @howo
  • @juancar347
  • @bartman67
  • @detlev
  • @walterjay
  • @storicious
  • @leancenter
  • @dailydab
  • @sanderjansenart
  • @achimmertens
  • @friendsofgondor
and 129 others

Comments · 1

  • @kachy2022(71)· 1d

    The poor rating really shows that the movie didn't really fit into horror movie. Thanks for sharing your review.