In 1998 two legendary directors released World War II films that couldn't be more different: Steven Spielberg's Saving Private Ryan is considered a masterpiece of the genre and the film's arrival was treated like a national event when it first hit theater screens. Audiences hailed the realism of the film's battle sequences while Spielberg was still able to play sentimental virtuoso with Ryan's rescue themes. There's no doubt that Ryan is an important cinematic accomplishment, but the masterpiece war film of 1998 was Terrence Malick's adaptation of James Jones' The Thin Red Line.
Red Line features an insane cast spotlighted in a number of separate-seeming scenes viewed through the eyes of shifting protagonists and linked together by the kind of voice over internal monologues often featured in Malick's films. Ryan offers a kind of penultimate WWII movie along with a nostalgic celebration of that film genre and America's Greatest Generation. Red Line is as subversive as Ryan is reverent — it's specifically an anti-war movie, and where most war films are direct and action-filled Red Line is surreal and full of quiet poetry.
And take a look at some of this cast:
Jim Caviezel as Pvt. Robert Witt Sean Penn as 1st Sgt. Edward Welsh Elias Koteas as Capt. James 'Bugger' Staros Nick Nolte as Col. Gordon Tall John Cusack as Capt. John Gaff Adrien Brody as Cpl. Geoffrey Fife John C. Reilly as Sgt. Maynard Storm Woody Harrelson as Sgt. William Keck Jared Leto as 2nd Lt. William Whyte John Travolta as Brig. Gen. David Quintard George Clooney as Capt. Charles Bosche Nick Stahl as Pfc. Edward Bead John Savage as Sgt. Jack McCron Tim Blake Nelson as Pvt. Brian Tills
Here's Nick Nolte talking about making the movie...
Please subscribe to my YouTube channel where I archive all of the videos I curate at Insomnia. Click here to check out more cinema posts.