← All reviews
Movie

September 5 (2025) - 70s Sweaty Newsroom Ambiguous Drama - REVIEW

Review by @skiptvads · 473d · of September 5

Source

I guess many would have confuse this movie with what actually happen back then during the 1972 Munich Olympics games hostage crisis but this movie is goes into the details of what went into the newsroom of ABC Sports. If I had to describe it this was a 70s sweaty, claustrophobic, chain smoking newsroom experience where ABC Sports producers were probably trying to byte more than they could at attempting to properly cover what was more of a journalistic specific situation rather than keep covering what was going on at the Olympics, not because this happen during a Sports event meant they shouldn't pass it to a department with more experience into this type of topics. The entire movie screams moral ambiguity that I know for many will be end up in a weird taste of a movie, instead of a feature of it would be a bug.

It was the 70s and tech was very very limited but from my perspective is so beautiful how this men and woman had this craftsmanship of someone getting the news out, either at interviewing the police radio or harnessing a phone to a studio mic.

Source In September 5, 1972, a group of Palestinian militants stormed the Olympic Village, killed two Israeli athletes and took nine hostages. ABC Sports was covering the Olympics when they accidentally had to be witness and report this global crisis. The movie is more about how ABC Sports producers took over the situation, how they mishandle it and how even though they were the only ones transmitting it live, it was very poor coverage that lead to miss information at multiple times, the cast did a great job at it, to transmit at times the desperation of not knowing exactly what and what not to cover, what to show on live TV and even how to say things to avoid what they fear the most, messing everything up giving information that was not accurate.

The movie begins with ABC Sports producer Geoffrey Mason; played by John Magaro, preparing for another day of Olympic coverage, its early and feels like a draggy day, until gunshots crackle over walkie talkies but nobody is sure if it was gunshots, I mean this is a never ever saw situation before so who would imagine. Inside minutes the crew knows that they are sitting on the biggest news story of the decade and this is when Roone Arledge; played by Peter Sarsgaard, the network’s slick executive, wants the story under Sports’ control, not handed over to News. Close to 17 hour adrenaline rush of making decisions, smuggling cameras into restricted zones, translating German police radio and debating whether or not to air unverified reports.

Source

Source It was not only the lives of the hostages what was at risk, but the ethics of live broadcasting life or death to 900 million viewers, its like watching a game at a stadium with all eyes on you and then in the very center of the field someone points a gun to a hostage in close contact. Not only what to show or not in live broadcast but also how and what to say? are they militants? guerillas? terrorist? the hole debate comes up within the crew that makes the movie even funny because they have no idea what they getting into.

To make things even worst, at their effort to cover the entire story, ABC Sports was transmitting life to the apartment where the hostage were, meaning the terrorist were also watching and this is why the first rescue attempt failed, this situations falls into one of those epic fail trending videos. Remember that time when ABC Sports basically told the terrorist they were going to be taken by surprise??. This entire drama cause the German Police to take the studio by force for a brief moment, this get way much worst when they lie about the hostages been rescued and everyone safe, I say lie because this was not confirm by anyone on the ground during the movie. Remember this is a movie "based" on real live events, although there is a lot that is going to be modified for entertaining purposes.

The movie does a great job with the 70s vibes, takes you to a tour of what was film making back in the day, from loading film canisters, how to frame a shot of a balcony, how limited cameras were, by the end of the movie you feel like film making was the profession that actually invented DIY stuff with every trick they come up during the movie.

Source

Source John Magaro sells the hell out of Geoffrey’s guilt, slumping against a wall like he’s been punched, he was the one basically at the wheel of the ship, its obvious he would feel he gave false hope to the many families around the world, he is the MVP here. He’s Geoffrey, sweating through his collared shirt like a man who is recently become aware that he is in way over his head, all nervous energy and full of moral conflicts. His performance is raw, like the way he barks orders of his team as his hands tremble, making you feel every ounce of his panic. Meanwhile, Peter Sarsgaard is Roone Arledge in full swagger of the corporate shark who is at once visionary and opportunist. It’s a masterclass in “the world is on fire but I'm cool” type of meme, as he casually lights a cigarette mid argument with ABC higher ups on the line and he about to broadcast what could end up in a massacre but its all about the rating and the amount of pair of eyeballs he can get the attention.

I really enjoy this movie as it serve as a tribute to the uselessness of the crew’s efforts, its the perfect representation of an Epic Fail meme transform into a movie. Sadly I think it is not the case of how it was announce during their marketing campaign and this might misguide certain part of the audience. The other side of it is that the movie kind of punts on its own themes, it avoids critiquing the system it try to describe so meticulously by refusing to show the aftermath the network, it would have been more interesting of what happens or what others think about the ABC Sports coverage, if back then people also though it was a disaster?. By no means I'm trying to pretend journalism is a black and white job although "don't trust, verify", that's where things got messy.

September 5 in my opinion has this technical perfection when it comes to strongly grasp the 70s vibe and how equipment works and its limitations back then, packed with some great performances. But I think this is the type of situations most of the time driven by politics and bureaucracy from higher ranks within the network, instead there was none and for that makes the movie feel weightless, like a documentary with no drama, yes this was not intention to be a documentary but it was the intention to add drama and keep people interested, it really felt lightweight on that department with no real pressure to the crew into following directions and then been the rebels. I have it at 7.5/10 ,love the craft, wish it had more back and forward.

#skiptvads, #inleo, #hive, #munich, #olympics, #terrorism, #journalism, #hostages, #abc, #broadcasting, #newsroom, #massacre, #israel, #palestine, #sports, #media, #crisis, #control, #television, #ethics, #producer, #coverage, #live, #thriller, #history, #politics, #drama, #documentary, #flixfinder

Posted Using INLEO