scrobble.life
← All reviews
Movie70

"Wuthering Heights": an Interpretation of Wuthering Heights

Review by @storicious 🏆#12 🔥45 🎵6.1k 🎬20 📺115 📚3 · 1h · of Wuthering Heights

I downloaded the movie the day I saw its trailer, and I do recall that Scrobble was in its initial stages. I also remember sharing the trailer on the platform. And then, the movie stayed in my downloaded file for so long. Whenever I thought of watching it, I ended up watching something else, mostly the Mentalist. Yes kind of addictive to it.

Anyways here I am after watching it. And brutaly honest, I did like it and not at the same time. Funny enough, while watching the Mentalist, I came across an episode where Cho is reading Wuthering Heights novel. And that day, I also downloaded the novel. However, I am not going to read it this way; I am going to buy the novel, and then read it. Books are just meant to be read by-hand, or at least this is what I believe.

Enough of uncalled yapping, time for the movie itself.


The movie is written and directed by Emerald Fennell. Written? Well yes! This version is not exactly Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights; rather it is Fennell's interpretation of it. Nothing wrong with it, I say. This is the beauty of literary world, you can have your own version of anything.

That is the reason this Wuthering Heights is written in quotation marks: "Wuthering Heights."

"Wuthering Heights" the name itself.

Now this is a unique take. The title is of the farmhouse which is named: Wuthering Heights. And the term, Wuthering, is drived from an old northern English dialect. The word is associated with turbulent weather, particularly strong winds, storms and the noise they produce.

Moreover, as per me, the metaphorical meaning behind is: the passionate yet destructive love. There is love, and there is no doubt in it; however, this is love is not conventional rather it is destructive obsession. The story will explain this thing itself.

So, let us go on the rollercoaster ride for this movie.


"Be with me always - take any form - drive me mad! Only do not leave me in this abyss, where I cannot find you! Oh, God! It is unutterable! I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!"

These are the last lines uttered by Heathcliff, and more importantly written by infamous Emily Bronte. Oopsie, I gave a spoiler I guess, but this thing cannot be unseen. The last scene really made me think, and this might be the reason for me reading the novel as soon as possible. Love is crueld indeed, enough to make a sane man go beyond sanity.

The Plot.

The story is set in 18th century England, the story revolves around Catherine and Heathcliff. Heathcliff is an orphan brought into the Earnshaw household by Catherine's father, and the name is given to him by Catherine i.e Cath.

In the beginning, he is supposed to be a slave, more like a doll for Catherine. However, as they grow up together, the two develop an extraordinary attachment. Their relationship is so full of affection, jealousy, childish adventures, and almost, inseparable emotional connection. All this without expressing truly to each other, it is their actions which prove.

But things are not particularly straightforward. Heathcliff is treated as an outside, while Cathering belongs to a privileged family, when compared to Heathcliff. Because of this particular reason, Catherine - or Heathcliff's Cath - is double minded. She does love Heathcliff, but the whole social status thing stops her.

She says: "It would degrade me to marry Heathcliff now."

And here are the words from before, from childhood.

"I will never go away. I will never leave you no matter what you do." - Cath.

And, before judging her, she still kept her promise. It was Nelly who played the trick, but I do not find her evilish as well.

As the story unfolds, Catherine eventually decides to marry Edgar, a wealthy gentleman, despite her feelings for Heathcliff. Unfortunately, thanks to Nelly again, Heathcliff overhears a conversations that makes him believe her Cath considers him socially inferior. He leaves. Then return years later with wealth, status and an entirely different personality.

But, you know the thing with love? It never changes, we just try to avoid it, escape from it. Same way, their attachment remains, and what next follows is obsessive destruction. Ending was sad, but I find it rationale and acceptable. Sorry Heathcliff!


Characters.

Well I doubt that anyone attached to cinema is unaware of these actors. And yes, these characters really played their roles well. Just few things seemed off, but I am let it pass.

Catherine played by Margot Robbie.

As for her character, she is complicated, impulsive, ambitious and emotionally demanding. She wants freedom, affection, social recognition and, perhaps most importantly, the ability to have everything i.e. to be rich and with her lover.

Her relationship with Heathcliff is particularly interesting because she does not simply love him; she identifies herself with him.

"Because he is more myself than I am."

This line alone by Cath is enough to prove that she truly loves him. And she proves it, just the next day. Only if it were not for Nelly to break the bond.

Heathcliff played by Jacob Elordi.

Now, Heathcliff is a completely different discussion compared to Catherine.

He is introduced as an orphan who becomes part of the Earnshaw household, but his childhood is far from pleasant. He experiences humiliation, mistreatment and discrimination, which eventually contribute to his resentment.

His attachment to Catherine becomes almost obsessive. Even after leaving, he cannot seem to detach himself from her. Even after years apart, he cannot think of anything straight - except Cath.

However, I would have appreciated if his inner conflicts were portrayed more carefully and honestly. Rather there was a rush, a bad thing to do. But nothing can be done, as movies have time limits. Alas!

Hong Chau's portrayal of Nelly.

Now she was my favorite character from movie. She really nailed her role. Although, her character is not close to Emily Bronte's writing; but she really made the whole experience worth it. Her character is the one which is closest to human nature. She expresses jealous, silence anger, and she is the one who knows most of the things. She, intentionally, let Heathcliff listen to Catherine's yes to a proposal. But when Cath acknowledged that she loves Heathcliff; she let it slide. And later on, when Cath is disloyal to her husband, she warns Mr. Edgar.

On moral grounds, I do not find anything wrong with her character. Because, most of the time, she is just doing which seems right. Although, the intentions behind those acts were clearly wrong - mostly out of jealousy or revenge. But, she has to survive in this world as well.


In the end, it was such a pleasant watch. However, ending really shattered my heart. Kudos to it for existing, at least, it proves I am human. Moreover, there are few concerning things as well: pacing and physicality over psychological depth. As for pacing, many things could have been explained well, but they failed to do so. Then after interval, half of the scenes are them being physically sexual. There is nothing wrong in it; but those scenes lacked psychological depthness. The expressions were good. There was love; there was insecurity. And then there was brutality in it.

"So kiss me again. Let us be doomed again."

My final thoughts are giving negative vibes, but believe me, it is a good watch. Enough to make one's thoughts go wild.


Platform Rating
IMDb 6.2/10
Rotten Tomatoes 57%
Personal Rating 70/100

Peace 🕊️

All pictures are taken from IMDb.

Rating: 70/100

Voted by
  • @alexis555
  • @pishio
  • @friendlymoose
  • @fieryfootprints
  • @pakx
  • @ahmedabbaci
  • @hive.pizza
  • @portsundries
  • @pizzabot
  • @hivetrending
  • @incantia
  • @joeyarnoldvn
  • @ingi1976
  • @fefe99
  • @fireguardian
  • @studio3141
  • @emsenn0

Comments

No comments yet — be the first.