scrobble.life
#sct

我對名聲等級的看法 My thoughts on reputation

我相信有些人買讚的原因是因為要衝名聲。名聲基本上只要衝上去,就很難或掉下來。除非一直有發文、留言,被等級更高的人點爛。名聲等級設定是取原本名聲點數的對數和一些計算,會讓名聲等級遇上去要越多的名聲點數,成一個等比級數變化。 在發文(評論)者的當前收益為零,點爛要降低別人名聲,要達成點爛人的名聲>0且>被點爛人的名聲。受到這設定影響,是造成我買讚衝名聲的原因之一。因為會有一種受制於人的威脅感。在此我想提出幾個建議,希望能改變這種狀況。

一、點讚代表同意某篇文章的觀點,也提高一篇文章、留言的能見度。除了能得到策展者獎勵SP,應該也要有名聲點數。而點爛沒有名聲點數。我建議給點讚人、作者比 0.25:0.75的名聲點數,在HF21後也一樣。這也能激勵人們好好點讚優文。

二、因為上述此點,得到名聲點數會更容易,我就也提出一個仿生的機制來平衡,讓名聲值更貼近現實。名聲值應該隨著時間逐漸減少,且名聲等級越高,減少越多。例如25級不掉,26級每天掉1點,26級每天掉2點之類。我想用等差級數,不過不知道這對新手會不會太多,對老手太少,可以大家討論看看掉名聲要用什麼公式。 這麼一來,如果想光要靠買讚提高名聲的,就要一直持續買才能維持,如果真有人這麼做,也能增加steem的需求😊

三、改成名聲低的點爛名聲高的也可以降名聲,但是掉比較少,我提議差X級,效果為1/[10^(1/9)]^X 高等級點爛低等級的,效果沒加成,維持一樣。

以上的建議,公式、數字都歡迎討論應該怎麼改比較恰當。

Some people buy votes, I believe one of the reasons is to gain the reputation. Basically, once the reputation go up, it's hard to decrease. Unless the person keeps posting, leaving comments, and always get downvote by people with higher reputation. The reputation level= [log(reputation points)-9]*9+25, it gets harder to elevate to a higher level. Takes about 30% of current reputation points to get to next level. When the reward of a post/comment is zero, it needs to meet that the reputation of the downvoter>0, and >the author's reputation. Affected by this, I buy votes to elevate my reputation. Cos I feel a threaten from people with higher reputation then me, and I can't take control of it. So I bring up some suggestion, hope to change the situation.

  1. Upvote means agree with the post/comment, and promote the post/comment by the way. Besides the curation reward, the votes should also gain reputation. And the downvotes gets nothing. I suggest to give the reputation to upvoters and the author by the ratio of 0.25:0.75, same after the HF21. This can also encourage people to upvote good articles and reward good authors.

  2. Due to this, people gets reputation easier. So I bring up with a biomimetic mechanism to balance this, and also makes it closer to the real society. The reputation should automatically declines by time. And it should drop quicker at a higher reputation level. E.g. no change in level 25, drop 1 reputation score each day in level 25, 2 per day in level 26... Anyway, I don't have a clear concept of how much a reputation score it needs, so I don't know if it is too much for a newbie and too insignificant to someone with high reputation. The formula is open for discussion. Then in this case, if someone buy votes to gain reputation, he/she needs to keep buying to maintain, if he/she do so, it increase the demand of steem😊

  3. Enable to lower the author's reputation when a downvoter has less reputation then the author. But should reduce the effect of the downvote. I suggest if the level difference # Header 1is lower by X, the decreased reputation of normal condition should be 1/[10^(1/9)]^X And if the downvoter has higher reputation, keeps the same, no additional effect.

The number, formula above are open for discussion to make it proper.

Comments · 13

  • @joshman(74)· 2597d

    Flagged for bid bot abuse @steemflagrewards. This post is not worth over $130.

  • @arcange(79)· 2598d

    Congratulations @john371911! Your post was mentioned in the Steem Hit Parade in the following category:

    • Pending payout - Ranked 1 with $ 136,52
  • @guruvaj(67)· 2598d

    It is hard to earn 1 reputation score these days.

    Posted using Partiko iOS

  • @lokiyngling(69)· 2598d

    That's Amazing!

  • @hiroyamagishi(69)· 2599d

    Bid bots made a questionable reputation. I think using bid bots for few times is good but frequent using is a bad habit, a rat poison in the room. I believe on sayings that your network is your network. People who connects on people make the best ROI. Cheers everyone

  • @samuel-swinton(65)· 2599d

    Great idea. I especially like that it encourage people to upvote the positive rather than downvote the negative.

    Posted using Partiko Android

  • @whatsup(76)· 2599d

    Interesting thoughts on Reputation, I just find this post to be over rewarded.

    DV. Keep posting.

  • @windenchanter(54)· 2599d

    好像什么的没明白有些什么实际意义

    Posted using Partiko Android

  • @steemitboard(66)· 2599d

    Congratulations @john371911! You have completed the following achievement on the Steem blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

    You received more than 3000 upvotes. Your next target is to reach 4000 upvotes.

    You can view your badges on your Steem Board and compare to others on the Steem Ranking If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

    Vote for @Steemitboard as a witness to get one more award and increased upvotes!
  • @nathen007(73)· 2599d

    The more your reputation increases due to due to using bid-bots to upvote total shit, the more your reputation changes from good to bad as it gets higher. Try to imagine somemone who bid bots shit posts to trending for a minute if you can. The community think they have a reputation as an absolute wanker. Reputations can be good or bad regardless of the numbers.

  • @liuzg(64)· 2599d

    我感觉现在的声望等级没多少实际意义。如果账户里的sp够多,声望低一些又有什么关系呢。

  • @swiftcash(64)· 2599d

    You received a 10.00% complementary upvote from @swiftcash 🤑 To stop similar upvotes from @swiftcash, reply STOP.

  • @team-cn(66)· 2599d

    Thanks being awesome NBC holder! Your 61.38 NBC earned you 6% team-cn upvotes!