scrobble.life
Reflections

Work-Life Fallacy

For the last couple decades and especially over the last one or so, the idea of "work-life" balance has been mentioned as something to find. But the problem with looking for it, is that it is like looking for a unicorn, a dragon, or the perfect partner - it doesn't exist.


image.png


It doesn't exist because there is just life. That is it. You or I do not have separate lives that we live in different places, nor do we change who we are in different situations, or around different people. You are always you, I am always me, but it sometimes feels like we do shift who we are, and how we behave. But it is a fallacy, we don't.

But in order to make sense of our world, we humans mentally compartmentalise, slicing up our experience into chunks that we can understand. We do this in many ways, like creating definitions and terms for things in order to distinguish one item from another, or one space from another, or one time from another. If we don't make these distinctions, our experience becomes incomprehensible.

However, this compartmentalisation brings with it issues that effect us in multiple ways. For instance, when we create definitions, those definitions can warp and change over time, even when we are the ones who made them ourselves. Factor in 8 billion people and shifting behaviour, and there can be a wide range of understanding about the meaning for a single term, where it gets used as originally intended, all the way through the spectrum to altogether incorrect.

Similarly, despite us separating past, present and future, only the present actually matters, because that is the only time that we are able to live and affect. People say "you need to live in the now" as if there is some other option. There is not. The past informs the present and is gone, and the future has not yet been lived. In fact, at least by my estimation, time itself does not exist at all, because if we were to break it down to its smallest unit (which is impossible) it is zero. That means nothing is moving, everything is dead, and nothing will move.

Think about it a little and you should understand, if you don't yet.

Anyway, then we also breakdown our spaces into pieces, as well as our experiences within those spaces - like work space and home space and personal space. Isn't all space person from your experience? And then, if all space is personal and we are always us, there isn't a work version of us and a home version of us, there is just us. Me.

Singular.

While it is convenient to compartmentalise our experience, we seem to often create a fantasy where the compartments don't overlap and affect each other. For instance, people talk about work-life balance where they look to limit their work to improve their personal life, but very few acknowledge that their personal life affects their work life. And I make this distinction knowing, that there are not two lives, there is just life. You live when you are at work, you live when you are at home, and each part of the equation is going to affect the whole outcome.

If you have a bad day at work, you might bring a bad mood home with you. But if you have a fight with your partner, you will take that mood into work with you too. Depending on your skills and strategies, you might be able to mitigate the negative effects, but many people cannot because they haven't built the skillset to be able to. Yet, they still believe they are able to compartmentalise, because mentally they have made the distinction between areas, even if their own behaviours do not adhere to the definitions.

I remember when I started going to the gym at around 18 years of age. I was very ill at the time, and very skinny. I got a little bit stronger I thought, but I was sick, there was only so much I could do. One day, I was working out there alone (I was usually with a group of friends) and a big, muscly bloke came up to me as I was benching sixty kilos and said, "I think you can do more than that - I'll spot you". He put on another 20kg and said "Don't worry, I've got it". I pushed hard and to my own surprise, I was able to push it. No spot required. Then he said, "I think you can do more" and put on another twenty kilos.

That was the first time I pushed 100 kilos.

In this case, I had underestimated my capabilities because my definitions about what I am and what I can do created beliefs that held me back. My compartmentalisation meant that I didn't even consider that it was possible for me to lift that much. What the big guy did was support me to reach more of my potential, even though I didn't believe I could. The problem comes because if it was left to me to decide what I could and couldn't do, I would never have even attempted to do more.

After that at the gym, I started exploring more of my physical limits, rather than stay mentally limited. And since then, I have furthered that exploration into more mental and emotional aspects of my life, to reach for more of my potential. I fail often, but when I do, there isn't an external excuse, there is just me to blame. But "blame" isn't the right word - I don't blame myself. Rather, I acknowledge that I haven't the skills yet, or perhaps I never will have the skills. I might be incapable of getting them, or I might be unwilling to get them.

The unexamined life is not worth living. Socrates

When searching this phrase, the explanation provided is:

The quote "the unexamined life is not worth living" is attributed to Socrates and suggests that a life lacking self-reflection, introspection, and critical thinking is devoid of meaning and value. It encourages individuals to question their beliefs, actions, and purpose in life to live more authentically and purposefully.

But have a look at that definition of the phrase and recognise that it is compartmentalising what life is. People tend to only see the reflection as a mental and emotional application, but it applies to life - All of life - Physical, mental, spiritual, fantastical. Life is a whole, not a series of pieces, and if we do not acknowledge and act on this, we will fall into the trap of limiting ourselves out of convenience, and overestimating the importance of the irrelevant. If one facet of the whole is out of alignment,

There is no life balance.

Taraz [ Gen1: Hive ]


Be part of the Hive discussion.

  • Comment on the topics of the article, and add your perspectives and experiences.
  • Read and discuss with others who comment and build your personal network
  • Engage well with me and others and put in effort

And you may be rewarded.


Comments · 13

  • @techstyle(61)· 390d

    I like to throw out this point for this is a deep reflection and I love how it captures how our need to define and categorize reality helps us function, yet also distorts it over time. Life always throws at us the very effort we brings in the world. But sometimes balanced is not enough towards redemption.

  • @seattlea(77)· 390d

    100 KG is 220 LBS that is a lot of weight to bench press. These days I bench press 150 LBS maybe could do 185 LBS as a max for 4 reps. During my younger days when I worked out with my co-worker who was an ex-wrestler and a wrestling coach in high school I could bench 200 LBS as my max with his spot. He was 20 to 40 lbs lighter than me but could bench press 240 pounds. I think that is because what muscles you train from childhood those are stronger and shorter arms create less leverage against you in bench press.

  • @beelzael(75)· 390d

    I never really liked those new-age-platitudes. They're so un-reflected, so empty. I think the work-life-balance was invented for those who are in conflict with their job, or who do not enjoy their work. I'm more on your side on that, work is part of life. I do think that everything has to have a balance, though over a long period of time.

    There was a time when I had to work a lot and had no time with family. Now I have a lot of time with family and work, but not so much for social encounters. I see it rather as phases of priorities, necessary ones.

    I think the intention is maybe that. To get those who overly do one side, in this case working, to take a step back and take care of the rest of their self. And, as always, it got twisted enough to be an excuse for everything.

    Anyway, here's the link to the article I wrote yesterday regarding a detail of education. Another one is in the works.

    https://peakd.com/hive-126152/@beelzael/pay-them-with-attention

  • @urrirru(65)· 391d

    Socrates said it well. Without self-analysis, we float through life, often not noticing what is important. Recently, I decided to go with my son to a museum in a neighboring city. We traveled 60 km in 40 minutes in a comfortable carriage with coffee and air conditioning. I told him that our ancestors traveled in carts between these cities under the hot sun for a long time. It is nice to realize the comfort of the modern world compared to other times.

  • @videoaddiction(72)· 391d

    Seems every aspect of our experiences affects the others, and being aware of this can assist us in living life more genuinely.

  • @tht(73)· 391d

    A person may often be unaware of their potential. A small criticism or motivation can change their life. A small incident you experienced could have led to even bigger things. There are dozens of people in this life who say, "I owe everything to a sentence from that person."

  • @princessluv(64)· 391d

    I really agree to this. Life isn’t split into neat sections. Everything we do affects everything else. Trying to keep work and personal life completely separate just doesn’t reflect how life actually works.

  • @bozz(83)· 391d

    As you kind of said, I think people tend to think of work life balance as more of a black and white thing when really there is a lot of grey in the middle. It's a spectrum that many find themselves on either end of. I try to stay in the middle. I have zero problem doing a little more work at home after leaving work for the day, but I don't let it interrupt other areas of my life.

  • @sanjeevm(78)· 391d

    if we do not acknowledge and act on this, we will fall into the trap of limiting ourselves out of convenience

    I have always tried to retrospect my life as you said and improvised like you but at times, I feel it creates some sort of anxiety, and needs strong determination to move forward. In contrast, I see almost ninety percent of people around me don't do that and they still live a happy life - so I believe it finally depends on our acceptance. Acceptance of how much we can do and be happy with that probably fits for all..

  • @aussieninja(70)· 391d

    I know I'm not going to convince you, because you can be very stubborn when it comes to the definition of things (re : empathy vs compassion), but I think work-life balance does exist. It's not a unicorn, it's just a normal thing people have to manage.

    I've had projects where the deadlines were extremely aggressive, and to meet those deadlines we all had to put in so much work, at one point I worked 24 hours straight. Our work-life balance was terrible, everyone was miserable, but we got it done. At the time we were proud of what we accomplished... but we all know there was a huge cost to our lives.

    In hindsight though, I wish I had pushed back or left that project, because all we did is confirm to management that they can abuse us and get away with it.

    Now I'd prefer to let a project fail if they set unrealistic timelines because I don't see any reason why they should be successful after failing to plan appropriately.

    Good leaders ensure their staff have a good work-life balance by protecting them from unreasonable requests, and bad leaders ask or demand their staff to work more than they are getting paid to.

  • @weone(62)· 391d

    Quite deep but also very true. Thanks for sharing your thoughts...

  • @toluwanispecial(71)· 391d

    Hmm, this is deep. The idea that work-life balance doesn’t actually exist because we only have one life is very true. We often try to separate work and personal life, but in reality, everything is connected. Our mood at home affects how we act at work and vice versa. Just like your experience at the gym and how you were able to navigate things with the support you received which shows how our own thoughts can limit what we believe we can do until someone challenges us to do more.

    I think we are sum total of our experience and our attitude to life. I agree that life isn’t about dividing everything into neat boxes. It's all one big experience, and we need to reflect on every part of it, not just mentally but also physically and emotionally. And if we want to live a meaningful life, we need to start questioning our purpose in life. Why do some things not work and what we need to do to make it work. Living a life of purpose is what we have to be deliberate about. We can't just live our life on default and believe everything will work out just on luck on chance. We shouldn't leave everything to chance. We should create an ideal life we wanted for ourselves.

  • @goldgrifin007(61)· 391d

    Dear @tarazkp !

    Would you sacrifice your present for the happy future of your family? I remember you sacrificing significant personal time and money in your life to leave Smallsteps your home as an inheritance!