scrobble.life
Movies & TV Shows

Television Review: And Those We've Left Behind (Fringe, S4x06, 2011)

(source:tmdb.org)

And Those We've Left Behind (S04E06)

Airdate: 11 November 2011

Written by: Robert Chiappetta & Glen Whitman

Directed by: Brad Anderson

Running Time: 44 minutes

No long-running genre series escapes the recycling bin. Fringe ran for five seasons and one hundred episodes, most of them built on a template of grotesque cold opens, laboratory deductions and a monster dispatched by the forty-minute mark; a show consuming that much narrative oxygen was bound, whether by accident or by the simple arithmetic of production, to start feeding on its own back catalogue. Sometimes this happened deliberately, as homage; more often it happened because a writing staff with a deadline reaches for a shape it already knows will hold. The clearest example sits in the fourth season, where the series reworked the architecture of the second-season episode White Tulip into And Those We've Left Behind. Ordinarily that would be grounds for complaint. Here, oddly, it isn't, because the later episode demonstrates that repetition need not be a symptom of exhaustion, and that a story told second time around by writers who have learned from their earlier mistakes can end up looking considerably better than the thing it imitates.

The episode arrives at a moment when Fringe had painted itself into a corner of its own making. Peter Bishop is still staggering under the reality of life in the so-called Yellowverse, the amber-tinted timeline in which he was never supposed to exist at all, having drowned in Reiden Lake as a child in 1985. The disorientation is compounded by his feelings for Olivia Dunham, which, in this version of events, are entirely unreciprocated; she regards him with the polite wariness one reserves for a colleague who has read one's diary. It is compounded further by Walter, who has responded to the sudden appearance of a grown son by treating him as an unnatural abomination and an unwelcome reminder of his own catastrophic past, retreating to his bedroom in a self-imposed exile and leaving Peter to be tolerated rather than welcomed. Phillip Broyles coerces the pair into working together anyway, because the alternative is worse. It is a shrewd piece of construction: the emotional weather of the episode is established before a single anomaly appears, and the audience is primed to read every subsequent event through the lens of displacement.

The case itself is a sequence of increasingly unpleasant incidents involving localised time dislocation. Objects, whole buildings, a moving train, flicker in and out of existence at locations where they stood four years previously. Broyles, never slow to suspect the obvious, wonders whether Peter's arrival tore the fabric of space and time and whether these ruptures are the invoice. The team sets about mapping the occurrences, and it is Walter who supplies the pattern: the locations, plotted on a map, describe a golden spiral, and the source should therefore sit at its centre. Fringe Division triangulates accordingly. The mathematics is elegant and, for once, dramatically useful rather than decorative.

The centre is confirmed in the grimmest manner available, when an FBI agent sent to investigate is torn apart mid-stride as he tries to cross the boundary. The house belongs to Raymond Green (Stephen Root) and his wife Kate (Romy Rosemont), once a distinguished professor of physics at Boston University. Kate retired three years ago after an Alzheimer's diagnosis; Raymond, a brilliant electrical engineer, has spent the intervening period not only caring for her but building a time machine from her own research. The device carries him four years into the past for forty-seven minutes at a stretch, long enough for the younger Kate to complete the formula that might let him remain with her permanently. The ripple effects of these excursions are what threaten to level Boston.

Having watched an agent die crossing the field between two points in time, Walter designs a Faraday cage capable of carrying a man through it. Peter volunteers and emerges in the basement to confront Raymond face to face. Meanwhile Lincoln Lee delivers the bad news that a fresh bubble has opened in a tunnel built during the last four years, which will flood and drown hundreds when the tunnel ceases to have ever existed.

It is the younger Kate who grasps the implications first. Unlike her husband, she is not blinded by the project; she demands an immunity deal for Raymond in exchange for shutting the machine down, and in doing so reveals that she completed the equation long ago, and that Raymond will find it in four years. He agrees, the bubbles dissolve, the tunnel stays dry. As the Division dismantles the apparatus, Raymond goes looking for Kate's notebook and discovers that she has blackened out the formula and left him a note telling him to go and live an ordinary life instead. The episode closes with Peter observing that the Green machine only functioned after his own arrival in this timeline, and fearing that he really is the indirect author of the disturbances. He moves out of the Federal building into Walter's old campus house and attempts to explain to Olivia what he and her other self once were to one another.

The parallels with White Tulip are so blatant as to be structural: time travel achieved by a scientist driven by profound personal loss, mayhem and destruction in the wake of the experiment, and finally a tragic figure compelled to surrender private happiness for the greater good. What scripwriter Robert Chiappetta and Glen Whitman do better is bind the case to the series' spine. Where White Tulip bolted Walter's confession onto Alistair Peck's tragedy and then abandoned it, this script makes Peter the hinge: a man out of time investigating a man out of time, and a couple refusing to accept a bereavement that the universe has already signed off on mirroring a son the universe has already deleted. The resonance is earned rather than asserted.

Part of the success lies in a structural gamble: the Greens are withheld until the second half. In lesser hands that would read as padding. Here it works, because the couple are better written than Peck ever was and, more importantly, far better performed. Root and Rosemont are married in life, and the shorthand shows; their scenes carry genuine anguish and genuine conflict, particularly Raymond's, who knows he is prolonging a woman who has already begun to leave. Their relationship is more credible and more relatable than one man's solitary ordeal, and the episode is smart enough to let Kate hold the moral high ground rather than turning her into a passive object of rescue.

The flaws are the familiar ones. The doomed agent is a Redshirt with a badge, introduced chiefly to be shredded so the audience understands the stakes; Lincoln is drafted in to witness a grand catastrophe that is then averted with a convenience bordering on the mechanical. These are the reflexes of network television, and they are what keeps the episode short of greatness.

The ratings, meanwhile, told their own story. Just over three million viewers made it a series low at that point, a warning of the erosion that would nearly end the show outright at the close of the fourth season. That a piece of work this accomplished should have been the one to set the record is a fair summary of Fringe's predicament: admired, discussed, and steadily abandoned.

RATING: 7/10 (+++)

IMDb link

Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/ InLeo blog @drax.leo Substack https://draxster.substack.com

LeoDex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax 1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e

BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7 BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk8

Comments

No comments yet — be the first.