Enemy of My Enemy (S04E09)
Airdate: 20 January 2012 Written by: Monica Owusu-Breen & Alison Schapker Directed by: Joe Chappelle Running Time: 44 minutes
Perhaps the most frustrating thing about Fringe, from the perspective of anyone who cared about it, was the persistent knowledge that it could have been considerably better than it was. The show’s ambitions — the parallel worlds, the moral rot at the heart of scientific progress, the terrible arithmetic of parental love — were repeatedly compressed into a shape that could survive on American broadcast television. Season four made this plain. The moment the general plot was allowed to breathe, unburdened of the distracting “mystery of the week” procedural machinery, it moved with real force. Enemy of My Enemy is one such example, and it is one of the strongest instalments the series produced in its later years.
It opens by discharging the previous instalment’s cliffhanger, set in the Redverse — or, more precisely, in that corner of the Yellowverse which passes for the Redverse. Fauxlivia and her Lincoln Lee race to the warehouse where they find the alternate David Robert Jones at work on his shapeshifters. They apprehend him, unaware that he has already been tipped off by the treacherous alternate Broyles, and not before he theatrically murders one of his own creations in order to suggest that he is capable of far greater damage. It is a flourish that reads, in the moment, as pure showmanship; in retrospect it is a statement of method.
Jones is duly delivered to Fringe Division and sits there radiating calm, self-assurance and the mild boredom of a man who knows something his captors do not. Then Peter volunteers to interrogate him, and the mask slips. Jones is visibly rattled that Peter — a man about whom he knows nothing — knows so much about him, and the discomfort curdles into a lethal gambit: he demands release, or his minions still at large will carry out a series of pre-planned terror attacks. One of them, intended purely as a demonstration, leaves sixteen people dead in a hospital emergency room.
The bargain is struck, with a tracking device slipped onto him, and Jones promptly evades his pursuers anyway thanks to another warning from Broyles. Peter and the alternate Astrid pick over one of his hard drives and identify the location of an abandoned quarry containing amphilicite, a mineral capable of tearing a hole in the universe given sufficient quantity. Peter arrives only to realise that the map is drawn from the Prime universe — Jones has crossed over to extract the mineral on the other side. Peter and the Prime Lincoln follow him back to the quarry and are too late; Jones, having secured his prize, returns to the Redverse while his minions hold off the FBI in a running firefight, during which Peter kills the top shapeshifter, Nadine. In the aftermath, a meeting between Fringe representatives of both universes is convened, and Peter lifts the assembled morale by pointing out that he has already killed the other version of Jones in his original universe and that here he represents an unknown quantity — a factor Jones cannot model, and one capable of wrecking his plans. Later, it emerges that Jones has been communicating from the Redverse with Nina Sharp in the Prime universe, preparing “Phase Two.”
Meanwhile, the Redverse’s Elizabeth has crossed over to meet Walter, telling him that she has forgiven him for everything he has done and begging him to help Peter get home. In the end, Walter agrees, and visits his son to offer his help.
Monica Owusu-Breen and Alison Schapker’s script is another triumph of efficient storytelling. It resolves a stack of major plot business, delivers another substantial cliffhanger, and does both inside a single episode’s running time, sprayed throughout with a series of impressive action set pieces handled with confidence by director Joe Chappelle. Very little here feels rushed, which is remarkable given how much the episode actually accomplishes.
It also benefits enormously from its guest cast. Jared Harris is a joy, reminding the audience precisely how ruthless the earlier incarnation of his character was and demonstrating that this one is no different — the smile never quite reaching the eyes, the politeness of a man who has already decided how you will die. The scene in which he executes one of his own “creations” does, briefly, tip the performance into over-the-top territory, but Harris is a good enough actor to keep it from toppling over. Orla Brady is far more believable as the alternate Elizabeth than she has been given room to be before, lending the character a warmth that makes her forgiveness of Walter feel earned rather than merely convenient.
Most productively, the episode redefines its alliances. It establishes clearly and without sentimentality that the two universes and their respective Fringe Divisions must co-operate in the face of a common enemy — that survival is now a shared project, however distasteful each side finds the other. The presence of traitors in their ranks, Sharp and Broyles, complicates that project enormously, and the knowledge that the men and women shaking hands across the dimensional divide may be reporting to Jones gives every scene of reconciliation a faintly poisoned edge.
It is one of the strongest instalment of the season so far, and it demonstrates what the series could do when it stopped marking time.
RATING: 7/10 (+++)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/ InLeo blog @drax.leo Substack https://draxster.substack.com
LeoDex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax 1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7 BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk8



