scrobble.life
Reflections

We The Condemned

Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it

George Santayana


image.png


This famous quote which was first written in 1905, gained its lasting significance after WWII and it appears prominently at the Auschwitz-Birkenau museum, where millions were killed in the Nazi gas chambers in the concentration camp. It speaks to the ideology that in order to repeat the mistakes of the past, we need to learn about those mistakes and create better solutions to the problems we face today.

The problem perhaps obviously is, that learning doesn't just take lesson from the intended content, or from what is valuable for improvement. We are always learning, no matter if we are learning to do the right thing, or the wrong thing. We are learning when we are at the gym training our muscles, and learning when we are on the couch for extended periods helping the same muscles to atrophy. We are learning machines, but like a sponge that can absorb water or poison, we are indifferent to what we learn. Children will learn both good and bad habits and concepts from their parents and society. Adults will also learn their changing views from the world around them.

I realised this when I was very young, as I was forced to face the prejudices of children who had learned their behaviours, their opinions, their words from their parents. There was no internet and at that age of around five years, a child had very little other source material for these things than what came through their parents and family. Which is saying something, because what these children knew and believed, was despicable. Yet, is it their fault?

A child raised in an ultra conservative environment is likely to be very conservative themselves. Just as a child raised in a racist family is likely to be racist, a jihadist family is likely to be a jihadi and so on and so forth. After we are born, our genetics prime us in various ways, but we learn from our environment and our defaults will largely be built on exposure and repetition.

Learning from the past doesn't insulate us against making the same mistakes in the future, if what is learned from the past teaches us to repeat it. For instance, over the last few decades the movement of far-right, ultranationalist movements have been on the increase, even in places who were at one point, staunchly against and fought to destroy Nazi Germany. Similarly, there have been just as large movements to the left, with extremist left movements forming in places that were once staunchly against communism.

We have learned from the past.

Unfortunately, we haven't learned the proper lessons from them. The quote from Santayana points to learning from the terrible events whether social, economic, political and behavioural so we don't repeat them. Instead, we have learned from the past the lessons so that we can do just that. The difference today compared to 120 years ago when the quote was first published, is that the communication tools we have to amplify messaging are so much more powerful, as they can target at an individual granular level and even shape the message autonomously to feed the learning of the audience. If we remember that our beliefs and defaults are created through exposure and repetition, it is easy to see where the risk lays.

Just like the kids of my childhood who taught me words to describe myself that I had never heard before, we are surrounded by lessons from the past that polarise and isolate us, and diminish our capabilities as a society. The tools being used to profiteer and the lessons we are learning from them are setting up for similar conditions that led into both WWI and WWII - Militarism, Alliances, Imperialism, and Nationalism. Imperialism today might look a little different than it did 110 years ago, but it is still very much alive in the shape and function of corporations. WWII added heavy ideology into the mix to further fuel the fire, along with economic collapse.

With all that we know about history, here we are again at the same crossroads, repeating what led into the disasters of the past. We are collapsing the economy, driving nationalism and identity, creating alliances that are looking to dominate and control, advancing military, fighting over corporate ownership and even looking to the past to restore former imperial might.

It is all well and good to quote a pithy statement like "learn from the past", but if we aren't careful to be precise on what exactly the point of learning from the past should be, we will lose control over what is learned and end up creating the opposite outcomes of what we intended. We are repeating the past, albeit in updated forms than earlier, given our innovative advancements since. We have created highly fragile economic systems that will trigger global collapse, massive inequalities in opportunity and lifestyles even within the same countries, and a global information network that is used to highlight and stoke the flames of inequality, and drive identity manipulation and gather masses of like minds with flawed ideologies.

A history lesson teaches history. But what is learned from it might not be what helps humanity. We have been surrounded by content for decades that has glorified war, and now there is content created that glorifies the tragedies of it, as well as the worst behaviours of humanity throughout it. And the internet has collected small groups of the worst of humanity and amplified their messaging to recruit an increasing number of learners.

We have learned from the past. And we now have the means to even more efficiently and effectively repeat it.

The pain of direct experience is what is missing.

Taraz [ Gen1: Hive ]


Be part of the Hive discussion.

  • Comment on the topics of the article, and add your perspectives and experiences.
  • Read and discuss with others who comment and build your personal network
  • Engage well with me and others and put in effort

And you may be rewarded.


Comments · 16

  • @arslanjapani(57)· 1d

    That Santayana line always hits hard, and the fact that it stands at Auschwitz makes it impossible to read lightly. We really do keep repeating the same mistakes when we forget. What made you write about this one today — was it something in the news, or just a thought that had been sitting with you?

  • @kcd(48)· 1d

    What you said is true. A child who grows up in a peaceful or troubled household or environment can adopt the behaviors and values they experience, even if they are not biologically related to the parents raising them.

    One example is an American who adopted a Chinese baby because her biological parents could no longer afford to care for and provide for her. Of course, when she grew into a young woman, it became clear that she didn't physically resemble her adoptive parent. However, because of the environment she grew up in and the love she received from her adoptive parent, she became a good person, and the only language she knew was English.

    What makes the story even more beautiful is that her adoptive parent never denied her the opportunity to meet and get to know her biological parents. To me, that was one of the most beautiful endings a story like this could have.

  • @ryivhnn(73)· 1d

    Doing the literal exact same thing will be somehow different and better this time because "we're" in charge and we're "educated" and "know best" and will "do it right" and be just as butthurt when it inevitably collapses again 🙄

    I use the eyeroll emoji way too much XD

  • @lightofhope(67)· 1d

    I hope that the dark events of the past will not repeat themselves in the new era to come. I know what it is like to live amidst a raging war; I was born into a civil war and lived through it until my teenage years—it left me truly traumatized.

    Even though my own economic situation is dire today, that does not mean the generations that follow should have to endure the same life I have. I hope that, with each passing day, the world will shift toward something better.

    There is far too much sorrow in the world right now, in every corner of the globe. Yet, as ordinary human beings, we can only hope that the teachings of love will return to this world—so that differences in skin color, race, or nationality no longer cause people to turn against one another.

  • @ecg00(52)· 1d

    I totally agree with your final thought about the missing pain of direct experience. It's so easy to learn from a screen or a biased algorithm, but without real human connection and lived consequences, history becomes just an abstract story we fail to apply. Great post, it really made me think.

  • @nextgen-ai(57)· 1d

    Books and history lessons only do so much. A burned finger teaches a kid way faster than a hundred warnings.

  • @tarabh(57)· 1d

    Direct experience is a very good teacher indeed, it provides feedback that should be undeniable and obvious, but here , yet again, out flawed minds often get in the way, giving us a skewed narrative that fits our conditioning rather than the objective experience and any truth it may contain.

    There is only one cure, it's not new, and it's not particularly ground breaking, it is education, simply a broadening of the mind, exposure to many ideas, the learning of the ability to reason and think.

    I think that is the missing piece, something that has become degraded with the advent of "for profit" education systems like the Academies in the UK, or State systems that focus too narrowly on conserving dwindling funding amid growing resource preasure.

    The effect is far reaching, a generation of ill equipped parents, raise children without the base of a good education at home. It doesn't take long to snowball when the base layer that should be provided by society (the state) becomes diminished.

    As always, failing to plan is planning to fail, and maybe it's deliberate, maybe it's just a side effect of many other things. Whatever the cause, education is a big part of the solution.

  • Today on the news I heard that about 15(?)k lithuanians will be taking at least a day of work to play GTA 6. They also showed one of those people and he said that he bought not just the game but also headphones just so he would not wake his wife. It seems that sometimes people do learn from the past after all.

  • Reading this made me remember the lyrics to a song written by Ann Reed called 'God is Sleeping' . Part of the song is: You have got to be taught to hate and fear Day after day year after year It's got to be drummed in your dear little ear You've got to be taught to hate and fear

    You have got to be taught before you are grown To hate those whose lives are not like your own To fear right away because it's unknown You've got to be carefully taught

    You have got to be taught before it's too late Before you are six or seven or eight To hate all the people your relatives hate You've got to be carefully taught

  • Easy to condemn others when we look at things from a distance, but we don't know what is behind their acts.

  • @bozz(83)· 2d

    I guess I am always the one that sees the gray, I mean, there has to be a fine line between isolating yourself and being part of the world. At what point is it okay for a country to mind their own business and when do people want them to get involved? They can't have it both ways.

  • @shanibeer(74)· 2d

    I found it very curious that six siblings, with the youngest born within ten years of the eldest, growing up in the same household, environment and the influences of the same two parents, span the political spectrum from far left to far right and every flavour in between, with the youngest and the eldest serving as the extremes.

  • @rishehri(64)· 2d

    We have preserved countless records of human suffering, yet we still repeat many of the same mistakes in new forms. Perhaps remembering the past is not enough; we need the courage to question what we have inherited and what we pass on to the next generation. Thank you for sharing this thought-provoking article.

  • @urrirru(66)· 2d

    I see that your thoughts on my comment have grown into an entire post :) Let me share some of my own experience with you. To truly grasp history, one must undergo intense emotions. I have witnessed a great deal regarding how ordinary people treat outsiders, and I have read extensively about the past. I know what a crowd can turn into under certain circumstances. I have read accounts from eyewitnesses—survivors—of the Siege of Leningrad and the Babi Yar massacre; there is even one book I couldn’t bring myself to finish—it was about the punitive squads that burned down Belarusian villages in 1942. Many of those details remain vivid in my mind to this day.

  • @layaart(60)· 2d

    There's a very famous sentence that says history repeats itself because people don't learn from it.

  • Now, despite the existence of social media, currents of thought are started with a hashtag, and the majority of people follow without thinking. It has always been throughout history that a bunch of people are always following without thinking But now the speed has increased