This one feels like going up a long hill and every episode is a stop, not in the bad way but its just that between work, the cold and irl stuff, I havent had the time to keep watching, last night I did one episode and realize "Backrooms (2026)" just drop so tonight I might have to make space to watch it and not another For All Mankind Episode. Still yesterday I went home ealry and decided to keep going, only for Mars to blow apart after Ed flew Lee to the ISN base, but the episode pulls back and lets the consequences spread through Happy Valley instead. News reports call Lee the first man on Mars charged with its first homicide, the Sons and Daughters of Mars get labeled a radical group, the governor pushes Palmer to restore order and honestly this all starts feeling like a colony choosing sides, this series really shows you we cant escape the reality from Earth and might not be able to start a "new world" since human behavior remains the same. Then Kelly learns from Dima that Eds cancer has spread and that he refused radiation therapy, and that changes everything for the rest of the episode. Alex hears enough to understand his grandfather is dying, disappears instead of answering Kelly and leaves her handling Ed while she searches for her son. This episode cares more about what happens after the rescue than giving us another chase. Ed is stuck in medical care, Kelly is trying to save him, Alex is avoiding a painful goodbye, and Palmer is slowly taking control of the colony. I expected fire and a full uprising, instead I got an old man refusing to give up his final choices while the world outside starts losing its own freedom, its kinda sad and a let down at the same time, after all Ed has been the center of this series for so long and I got a personal attachment to it since its the one that show me how good Appletv quality is, but I would still agree that switch worked because one family crisis can feel bigger than an entire planet when the time is running out.
- IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7772588/
- Platform: PRIME VIDEO
The Baldwin's as usually easily the strongest part of the episode, starting with Kelly pushing treatment after Dima explains the cancer and Ed making it clear he never wanted her managing his remaining day, you cant tell a guy like him how to go about his last days alive, just doesnt work with Ed. Kelly sees refusing care as giving up, Ed sees the hospital bed as losing control so its a clash as both have different perspectives of what caring for Ed is. Alex handles it differently, riding his bike and ignoring messages until Dev finds him and hears his fear that he disappointed Ed. Then Dev talks about losing his own father young and asks what people want to do with the time they have left and that gets Alex moving. The payoff at Ilyas bar is damn good, Ed sits there in a hospital, chooses Love Me Tender, pours Alex a shot, then raises a glass to Karen, turning one small drink into a family memory that nothing else on space can replace. Kelly and Alex stop trying to drag him back to medical care and take him to his room instead and Alex stays beside him this time while Kelly follows Eds advice and goes to inspect Sojourner One for the Titan mission. None of it needs a speech, the bar, the shot and Kelly walking toward that old ship say enough on their own, for an episode surrounded by arrests and murder accusations, the best scene is still three people sharing a drink because they know there may not be another chance.
Aleida and Margo bring back the engineering side of For All Mankind and their Titan work does feel like the same as Ed pushing Kelly and Alex toward whatever comes after him. Things kinda spike up when a rival mission plans to reach Titan before Helios, Aleida visits Margo in prison, and Margo proposes rebuilding Sojourner One after roughly twenty years on Mars, though the ship needs serious work Aleida cannot supervise from Earth. Margo pushes her to delegate at Helios and go to Mars herself, even joking that she has only made good decisions while sitting in prison and the joke works because their regular visits already show how much remains between them, I really love what they have done with Margo character through all this seasons, both phisically and as how her character has growth, almost same as Ed refuse to die. Aleida admits Margo should be leading the work, but Margo knows the trip belongs to the engineer who can still leave the room and touch the ship. Their goodbye hurts because Aleida is not just accepting a Mars assignment, she is leaving the person who helped shape her career behind. Later Margo returns to her cell, puts on her headphones and watches time pass while Aleida prepares to rebuild the machine that could carry people toward Titan, one handed an impossible problem, the other left with a wall and a clock. It connects with Kelly inspecting Sojourner after leaving Ed too, the same old ship becoming where two women choose work while facing personal loss and this episode remembers that rockets are never only machines, they are also how mentors pass work forward when time is almost gone.
The episode was pretty good for me, specially after been a while without watching, but I got an issue with Boyd and Miles get squeezed between the Baldwin scenes, even though both situation might deserved more weight. Boyd keeps asking whether Lee killed anyone and brings Kuragins unrecorded night work to Palmer again, only to get reminded her bad call on Earth ended with an officer getting shot. Palmer uses that mistake to shut her down, but Boyd cannot leave it alone with the illegal work and murder victim pointing toward hidden cargo. She heads into the sublevels alone, questions a worker who saw the fight and asks what Kuragin was moving inside those crates, until someone knocks her out after she follows him around a corner. She then wakes in medical care, talks with Fred about Mars giving people another start, then learns Palmer put her on six weeks of leave and the episode barely gives her a moment to react to losing the thing that gave her new start meaning. Miles has the same problem after Lily gets arrested for painting Free Mars across the governor's and he begs Palmer not to damage her future before college. Palmer wants cooperation in return, Lily gets released and her friends see Miles shaking his hand before anyone explains why, Lily refusing to treat it like a lesson while Miles thinks protecting his daughter matters more than looking clean to people fighting authority, so I get both of them, which is why their choices deserved more room to breathe.
The episodes handles Eds so well, even though it center about him finally hitting and end I feel like the episode did a lot and handle it just as good with enough importance as it should, it works because everyone finally accepts that they cannot hold on to everything, especially after an episode with so many other stories fighting for space. His Korean War memories are not there just to fill in another part of his past. Seeing the young Ed injured behind enemy lines, saved by Shane Barnhill and then unable to save Shane in return, explains why helping Lee matters so much to him now. Ed has carried that failure for most of his life and getting Lee safely across the line feels like the closest he will ever come to making peace with it, and I think that is why the final scene does not need a loud medical emergency or a long goodbye speech. Alex comes back and stays beside him, while Kelly leaves to inspect Sojourner and continue toward Titan, which is exactly what Ed wants her to do. He gets his family close without asking them to stop living for him and that makes the goodbye hit harder than something more dramatic probably would have. The rest of the episode is still busy setting up what comes next, with Boyd continuing to dig while Palmer closes in, Miles accepting a dirty bargain for Lily, Aleida stepping into the position Margo cannot take and Margo still searching for one last answer. Some of those stories feel rushed, especially Boyd and Miles, and I expected the episode to spend more time on the growing conflict inside the colony. Still the episode finds its emotional center whenever it looks back at Ed. The bar scene, the connection between Shane and Lee, Alex coming back and Ed pushing Kelly toward Titan give the episode a sense of closure without making everything feel finished. I give episode three an 8/10, it is definetly crowded in places but the quiet Baldwin goodbye is some of the strongest part so far for the season.
#forallmankind, #forallmankindseason5, #forallmankindreview, #homeepisode, #edbaldwin, #kellybaldwin, #alexbaldwin, #aleidarosales, #margomadison, #devayesa, #milesdale, #lilydale, #pkboyd, #palmer, #sojournerone, #titanmission, #happyvalley, #marscolony, #marspolitics, #appletv, #scifiseries, #tvreview, #episodereview, #spacedrama, #season5
Rating: 80/100
Originally posted through scrobble.life/tv.
