scrobble.life
← Back

Title · no scrobbles indexed yet

Chinatown

The first scrobble for this title is still propagating, but a community review is already indexed below.

Reviews

Longform community posts about this title

Chinatown Is One Of The Greatest Neo-Noir Films Ever Made And A Masterclass In Atmosphere, Writing, And Slow Burning Tension. It Is The Kind Of Film That Gets Better Every Time You Watch It.@thefed45d
Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post

Comments

No comments yet — be the first.

5 more reviews

  1. Chinatown - when crime becomes an art@reviewzzz482d

    If you like crime and mystery movies, Chinatown (1974) is one of the movies you must watch. This movie is not just a classic film noir, it is a masterpiece that takes you on a journey through conspiracies and deception in an unnatural way.

    The story revolves around Jake Gates, a private investigator played by Jack Nicholson, who starts the case when a woman asks him to monitor her husband to make sure he is not cheating on her. But like any respectable crime story, the issue turns out to be much bigger than just marital infidelity, and reaches political corruption and water tampering in Los Angeles, and the city itself feels like a main character in the movie.

    The thing that attracted me most in this movie is the writing and dialogues, every scene is calculated with skill, as if every word has a deeper meaning that you will understand as the events progress. Other than that, the general atmosphere of the movie, with the dim lighting and cinematography that gives you a sense of mystery, makes you live the atmosphere of the thirties in all its details.

    And of course, the acting was top notch. Jack Nicholson played the role of Jake Gates with his sarcastic and intelligent style, and you feel that he is a hero living in a world full of corruption, but at the same time he is not a perfect hero, he has his flaws and mistakes. Faye Dunaway in her role was a mystery in herself, and every time you think that you have understood her character, you discover something new that turns the tables.

    As for the ending, it is truly one of the strongest endings you can see in the cinema. I will not spoil it, but I will tell you that it is the kind that leaves you shocked and unable to believe what happened.

    Chinatown is not just a crime movie, it is a movie about corruption, about power, and about how unjust the world can be, and all of this is said in the simplest sentence at the end: "Forget it, Jake. It's Chinatown."

    My rating review ... (9 / 10)

    Image Credit

    Previous Reviews

    Invincible Review - Anime and Superheroes

    Enforcement Review - Danish Action and Creativity

    Better Days Review - Humanitarian Issue again

    Thanks

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post
  2. Chinatown@steemychicken1688d

    This is not just a regular movie review but more of a reminder of what film noir can be, and cinema in general.

    Chinatown (1974) The first time I saw the movie, the word "memorandum" was unknown in Greece. And yet, despite my young age and minimal cinematic education, I really liked this film. I didn't quite understand why, apart from the fact that it had a very good plot.

    Flash forward to today, when I rewatched this movie last weekend, in a semi-drowsy state and flirting heavily with burnout. Believing that I would relax further by watching the film to the point of falling asleep, the exact opposite happened: I woke up, stayed glued to the screen for the entire duration of the movie. I knew the ending very well and was eager to see what would happen next. I was anxious to see how Nicholson would manage to unravel the mystery, knowing what lay behind every corner and every scene.

    I believe this is where the charm of this particular movie lies. Having more cinematic knowledge, I was able to enjoy every aspect of it tenfold, to recognize its scriptwriting brilliance, its incredible shots, and, of course, its memorable performances. However, I also realized that my love for noir began with this film, both in its cinematic and literary forms. The hero's quest to make sense of a deeply corrupt world, where every crime hides a multi-layered conspiracy within another multi-layered conspiracy.

    Is there catharsis at the end? Not necessarily, but there is the reminder that you've just experienced an exciting two-hour journey. That is your reward.

    If you've seen this movie, watch it again. If you haven't seen it, do yourself a favor and discover the captivating power of cinematic noir.

    That's all, have a good weekend.

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post
  3. Chinatown (film): Rated as one of the "best ever" but I don't understand the appeal@netflixr1290d

    To premise my opinion I'll mention that as far as classic "best ever" films are concerned, I am generally unimpressed. I think that the advancements in film-making make it difficult or impossible to really appreciate the majesty of these films unless one was alive when they were released. I can say that this is true about the original Star Wars trilogy that when viewed through the eyes of someone that is young right now, and completely unaware of the films' legacy, they would probably think they were boring and poorly made even though most of us know that the opposite is really the case.

    I got bored with what Netflix had on offer recently an decided to consult a list of the best films ever made and Chinatown was ranked in the mid-20's on said list.

    image.png src

    Since it starred a young Jack Nicholson in his prime I figured there was no way that this one could go the wrong way with me but after watching it, I gotta say that I just don't get the hype nor why it is featured so high on a list of best films of all time.

    Perhaps it was very difficult to film since it is based in the 30's but was filmed and released in the early 1974. It may also be some sort of preferential treatment that is being shown to director, Roman Polanski, as this is frequently done for many directors. I felt the same way about watching several other classic "best" films one the most noteworthy being Lawrence of Arabia. While I can appreciate how momentous the filming of that film might have been, the acting is a bit wooden and the story is actually quite boring. I feel the same way about a lot of what happens in Chinatown.

    image.png src It's over two hours long as well

    The story here is of a private detective named Jake (Nicholson) who gets hired to investigate a suspected affair, as seems to be his forte in his profession. The affairs ends up containing a lot more devious things than someone just cheating on their spouse and Jake ends up getting wrapped up in a lot of it - in many instances against his own will where his very clients are lying to him and making his job more difficult.

    There are plenty of problems with the actual presentation as well such as telephone calls that are crucial parts of the story that are entirely too quiet for anyone not sitting in a dead quiet theater wouldn't be able to hear at all. Without a subtitle track I had no choice but to ramp up the volume to near maximum on my TV just to be able to hear what was being said.

    [src](https://a.ltrbxd.com/resized/sm/upload/sy/yq/6d/o6/chinatown-1200-1200-675-675-crop-000000.jpg?v=0197557a3b)

    There isn't a lot of action and almost all of the fight scenes are pretty comical with their very poor execution of choreography and inserted sounds when a kick or punch sound-effect comes into the mix. This story is very dialogue-driven and that is fine and to be fair most of the dialogue is meaningful without a bunch of dreaded filler to simply get the runtime up.

    In the end I went back and watched it again because I fell asleep on the first run. I re-watched in order to try to figure out what it is about this film that makes people so "gaga" about it and the reasoning for it being ranked above things like Apocalypse Now and Gladiator, both of which I believe to be superior films in every way.

    Thinking back on Chinatown I think I would groan if someone were to tell me that I had to sit through it again with them, ever. It just isn't very entertaining. Maybe there is some film-school stuff in there that I am too much of a pleb to understand, but for me, I don't really see anything historically meaningful, or even subtle hints eluding to things like class warfare or societal issues.

    [src](https://1.bp.blogspot.com/_Ne5Lb2SiFHg/S89u0LdruhI/AAAAAAAAvlo/b9T7ZRRkdxE/s1600/chinatown+slap.jpg)

    In one particularly funny sequence that is most-likely famous to some degree, Jack Nicholson has to repeatedly slap Faye Dunaway in order to get some information out of her. These slaps seem to genuinely make contact with her face and I wonder how many times they had to shoot that in order to get the final take. The acting in this scene on Faye's part isn't very good so I'm thinking maybe they only did it a couple of times. It does appear to be one continuous take as well, which is impressive I suppose.

    Should I watch it?

    I hesitate to tell anyone that they definitely shouldn't watch this but at the same time I really don't think that the people of today are going to find this entertaining enough to actually sit through the whole thing. I suppose if you wanted to go down a nostalgic trail of Nicholson's past then go ahead. I do think that if you were going to do this that you would be much better off watching One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest though, because that is a much better film that is actually really good.

    If you are a film nut and want to see what the world considers to be one of the best things ever made then I say go ahead and watch Chinatown. However, if you are in this film game for pure, raw entertainment, I think that this one will let you down as much as it did me.

    Chinatown is not currently on Netflix. You can watch it on HBO Max and of course, there are torrent options as well.

    50119633_m.jpg

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post
  4. Chinatown (1974): un clásico detectivesco | a detective classic@cristiancaicedo1457d

    A cult movie | Una película de culto

    It's not always easy for me to choose which movie to watch next: there are so many on my list that I can spend half an hour choosing one. So I had an idea. Whenever I'm not sure which movie to watch, I'll pick one by its title, in alphabetical order. For example, the first time it occurred to me I chose After life; then Burn after reading and the last one, so far, Chinatown; It seems like an eccentricity (and maybe it is) but it helps me to choose faster and the experience has been pleasant, so I will continue applying the idea.

    No siempre se me hace fácil escoger qué película ve a continuación: hay tantas en mi lista que puedo pasarme media hora eligiendo una. Así que tuve una idea. Cada vez que no esté claro sobre qué película ver, escogeré una por su título, en orden alfabético. Por ejemplo, la primera vez que me ocurrió escogí After life; luego Burn after reading y la última, hasta ahora, Chinatown; parece una excentricidad (y a lo mejor lo sea) pero me ayuda a elegir más rápido y la experiencia ha sido grata, así que seguiré aplicando la idea.

    Years ago, talking to an acquaintance about cinema, he suggested that I watch Chinatown a 1974 police thriller (neo-noir) directed by none other than Roman Polanski and starring one of the greats of cinema, Jack Nicholson. The collaboration of this duo was already striking enough to want to see it, but for some reason it was still on my to-do list. The film is set in the city of Los Angeles, in the late 1930s. Detective Gittes (Nicholson), who specializes in divorce, is visited by the wife of a well-known businessman named Mulwray, the head of the city's Water Service, and she suspects that her husband is cheating on her. This is how almost all of Detective Gittes' cases begin, with one of the parties suspecting their partner; the only difference now is that the name of a well-known person in the city is involved and who at that moment is in the middle of a controversy: the refusal to build a dam that would help the peasants and the city to cope with a terrible drought that they have suffered for some time.

    Hace años hablando con un conocido sobre cine, me sugirió que viera Chinatown un thriller policíaco (neo-noir) de 1974 dirigida nada más y nada menos que por Roman Polanski y protagonizada por uno de los grandes del cine, Jack Nicholson. La colaboración de esta dupla ya era de por sí lo suficientemente llamativa como para querer verla, pero por alguna razón seguía en mi lista de pendientes. La película se ambienta en la ciudad de Los Ángeles, a finales de los años treinta. El detective Gittes (Nicholson), especializado en divorcios, recibe la visita de la esposa de un empresario muy reconocido de apellido Mulwray, el jefe del Servicio de Aguas de la ciudad, y ella sospecha que su marido la engaña. Así inician casi todos los casos del detective Gittes, con una de las paartes sospechando de su pareja; la única diferencia ahora es que se ivolucra el nombre de una persona reconocida en la ciudad y quien en ese momento está en medio de una polémica: la negativa a construir una repesa que ayudaría a los campesinos y a la ciudad a sobrellevar una terrible sequía que han padecido durante algún tiempo.

    Seeing a woman suspect a man's infidelity is a cliché so ingrained in the collective imagination that we immediately take her side, especially when we see the detective team take photos of the man with another woman, younger than his wife. It seems that everything becomes clear in the first half hour of the tape and we think If everything is true, what can happen now?

    Ver a una mujer sospechar de la infidelidad de un hombre es un cliché tan arraigado en el imaginario colectivo que inmediatamente nos ponemos de su parte, sobre todo cuando vemos al equipo del detective tomar fotos del hombre con otra mujer, más joven que su esposa. Parece que todo se aclara en la primera media hora de la cinta y pensamos Si todo es cierto, ¿qué puede ocurrir ahora?

    The answer: many things. Many. I'll just say two to pique your curiosity enough to watch the movie, but I'll keep the rest (perhaps the most surprising revelations) so you'll be surprised too. The first of these revelations is that, shortly after following Mulwray, the businessman appears dead, suicide? homicide? accident? all possibilities must be evaluated. The second revelation - and it is the one that triggers the rest of the plot - is that Mulwray's wife is not really his wife. That is, Mulwray's real wife arrives at Detective Gittes' office to talk to him. We wonder, who was the other woman then? who knew about the businessman's infidelity and wanted to expose him? to what end? Was this other woman hired by the real wife? what kind of person was Hollis Mulwray really? After receiving the compromising photos from his collaborator, Gittes had delivered them to his client and in the blink of an eye the scandal jumped to the press, exposing not only Mulwray but also Gittes.

    La respuesta: muchas cosas. Muchas. Sólo diré dos para picarles la curiosidad lo suficiente como para ver la película, pero me guardaré el resto (acaso las revelaciones más sorprendentes) para que ustedes se sorprendan también. La primera de estas revelaciones es que, al poco tiempo de estar siguiendo a Mulwray, el empresario aparece muerto, ¿suicidio? ¿homicidio? ¿accidente? hay que evaluar todas las posibilidades. La segunda revelación - y es la que dispara el resto de la trama - es que la esposa de Mulwray no es en realidad su esposa. Es decir, a la oficina del detective Gittes llega la verdadera esposa de Mulwray para hablar con él. Nos preguntamos, ¿quién era entonces la otra mujer? ¿quién sabía de la infidelidad del empresario y quería exponerlo? ¿con qué fin? ¿esta otra mujer fue contratada por la esposa verdadera? ¿qué clase de persona era realmente Hollis Mulwray? Tras recibir las fotos comprometedoras de parte de su colaborador, Gittes las había entregado a su cliente y en menos de lo que canta un gallo el escándalo saltó a la prensa, exponiendo no sólo a Mulwray sino también a Gittes.

    From there, the story becomes a parade of increasingly intricate revelations that end in a hopeless and unexpected ending. Added to this great script that won the Academy Award is a masterful performance by Jack Nicholson and a character that suited him very well. Jake Gittes is a determined, smart, action man, someone who doesn't wait for things to happen, but makes them happen, goes where he has to go, even if he puts himself in danger and stops at nothing until he achieves the truth, it hurts who hurts. It doesn't mean that he has impeccable ethics, after all his business is based on discovering the sins of other people, but although he's violent, reactionary and has more than one pending account, he's someone who takes his case to the end, he ain't a quitter, so if you count on him, you do it to the last consequences.

    A partir de allí la historia se vuelve un desfile de revelaciones cada vez más intrincadas que terminan en un final desesperanzador y poco esperado. A este gran guión que obtuvo el premio de la academia se suma una interpetación magistral de Jack Nicholson y un personaje que le quedó muy bien a él. Jake Gittes es un hombre decidido, listo, de acción, alguien que no se queda esperando que las cosas pasen, sino que las hace pasar, va allí a donde tenga que ir, aunque se ponga en peligro y no se detiene ante nada hasta conseguir la verdad, le duela a quien le duela. No quiere decir que tenga una ética intachable, después de todo su negocio se basa en descubrir los pecados de las demás personas, pero aunque es violento, reaccionario y tiene más de una cuenta pendiente, es alguien que lleva su caso hasta el final, no renuncia, así que si cuentas con él, lo haces hasta las últimas consecuencias.

    I really enjoyed that 1930s detective vibe and I think this is the first time I've seen a 1970s movie with a story set just before WWII. Usually these police movies - the ones I've seen - used to be much more recent, or from the 1950s. That retro element - like making a movie set in the seventies today - also gives the story a romantic touch, the evocation of a past whose setting no longer exists, the cars, the places, the costumes, the customs, but In turn, it demonstrates how timeless the vices and sins of men are. Corruption, murders, suicides, disappearances, shady deals, deception, betrayal, blackmail, are aspects that have occupied the screen, the news and the history of humanity since time immemorial. Perhaps, deep down, we are still the same as always.

    Disfruté mucho ese ambiente detectivesco de los años treinta y creo que es la primera vez que veo una película de los años setenta con una historia ambientada justo antes de la segunda guerra mundial. Normalmente estas películas policíacas - las que he visto - solían ser mucho más reciente, o de los años cincueta. Ese elemento retro - como hacer hoy una película ambientada en los setenta - le da también un toque romántico a la historia, la evocación de un pasado cuyo escenario ya no existe, los autos, los lugares, el vestuario, las costumbres, pero que a su vez demuestra lo atemporal que resultan lo vicios y los pecados de los hombres. Corrupción, asesinatos, suicidios, desapariciones, negocios turbios, engaños, traiciones, chantaje, son aspectos que han ocupado la pantalla, las noticias y la historia de la humanidad desde tiempos inmemoriales. Quizás, en el fondo, seguimos siendo los mismos de siempre.

    If you are a lover of detective films, Jack Nicholson, police thrillers or neo-noir cinema, surely you have already seen Chinatown, but if the case is that it is still on your to-watch list, give it a chance to this film that had eleven Oscar nominations and won three BAFTAs and four Golden Globes, including best dramatic film. Apart from this one, what other detective movie would you recommend? I read you in the comments.

    Jack Gittes

    Si eres amante de las películas de detectives, de Jack Nicholson, de los thrillers policíacos o el cine neo-noir seguramente ya viste Chinatown, pero si el caso es que aún está en tu lista de pendientes dale la oportunidad a esta película que tuvo once nominaciones a los Oscars y se llevó tres BAFTA y cuatro Globos de Oro incluyendo el de mejor película dramática. Además de esta, ¿qué otra película de detectives recomendarían? Los leo en los comentarios.

    Reviewed by | Reseñado por @cristiancaicedo


    Other posts that may interest you | Otros posts que pueden interesarte:

    After life (1998): a memory for eternity / un recuerdo para la eternidad |

    --- | ---

    Toni Erdmann (2016): a weird sense of humor and an important message / un sentido del humor extraño y un mensaje importante |

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post
  5. Chinatown (1974) - "Politicians, ugly buildings, and whores all get respectable if they last long enough."@dedicatedguy2175d

    image.png

    I have known about this movie for a long time, how it was considered one of Jack Nicholson's greatest movies, and how the same can be said about its director, Roman Polanski. I knew that eventually, I would find the time to watch it and that's what happened last night.

    The first thing I should write is that the movie was well-made, but I was expecting something even greater. Maybe I was hyped and with too high expectations after knowing all the praise this movie received. I do think it was good but thinking it can be considered a classic would be too much in my opinion.

    In the movie, Jack Nicholson plays a private investigator that is hired by a woman to basically spy on her husband because she thinks he is cheating on her. That looks like a very straight forward task for a private investigator right? Except that in this case, nothing is what it seems and by accepting this job he went straight to the deepest rabbit hole involving local corruption, lies, and dark secrets.

    image.png

    This private detective will have to deal with very dangerous people if he wants to remain alive and discover what is really happening in this place. These aren't lowlife gangsters but rather well-financed organized mafia with tentacles reaching into all sorts of organizations. The detective is clearly out of his depth in this story.

    The plot is dark but not really disturbing, it is dark because the criminals have so much power that it is almost impossible to do anything about it, much less if the only person trying to expose anything is a single private detective.

    If you enjoy movies about detectives and the film noir genre, then it would be a good choice to watch this flick. The movie doesn't have explosive moments but it slowly unravels the intricate corruption exposing how deep can the human soul rot in the search for power.

    image.png

    The best

    • Jack Nicholson gave a great performance in this film.
    • It has a tragic and well-written plot with human evil as the central point.

    The worst

    • For extremely sensitive people this film might be too bitter.

    More information: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0071315/ Review: AAA In numbers: 7.5/10

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post