scrobble.life
← Back

Title · no scrobbles indexed yet

Pale Rider

The first scrobble for this title is still propagating, but a community review is already indexed below.

Reviews

Longform community posts about this title

Film Review: Pale Rider (1985)@drax1657d
Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post

Comments

No comments yet — be the first.

4 more reviews

  1. Noob Film Review - PALE RIDER (1985), Clint Eastwood@nazirullsafry1845d
    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post
  2. Noob Film Review - PALE RIDER (1985), Clint Eastwood@nazirullsafry1846d

    pale.jpg

    "The hero’s death and resurrection is a model for the casting off of the old life and moving into the new." - Joseph Campbell

    A young girl, Megan Wheeler prayed for a miracle after her dog got killed in a raid. John Wick cometh? Not even close. It’s Clint Eastwood as the Preacher.

    A classical Hollywood Western, "clean up town" themed film. Yes. But not a generic one. On top of the brilliant screenwriting lies some reference to myth and metaphor.

    HOW TO INTRO YOUR HERO 101

    pale2.jpg

    No word needed with those eyes. A mark of a great actor

    Intro 1. When Megan was praying for a miracle, a silhouette appears on screen of a rider at the same time. He is the miracle.

    Intro 2. The Preacher’s first screen presence is a long shot with the mountain range as his background looking at a group of bullies beating down Hull Barret who trying to get supplies for his town folks. The second time the bullies look, the Preacher is gone. The next thing they know, all got beaten down single-handedly.

    Intro 3. Then, the Preacher’s first arrival to the village came at the same time when Megan Wheeler is in the middle of reading a passage from Chapter 6 of the Bible.

    Her mother then gaze through the window and see exactly what her daughter is reading,

    "And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death,"

    Megan joined her mother looking at him and continues "and Hell followed with him..."

    No special effects and self-introduction. Needed. Not even a title intro.

    SHOW DON'T TELL

    This is what is missing in today's cinema. Everything has to be spoon-fed or otherwise, it will be deemed rubbish.

    It is the mystery of who he really is that gave him the aura and presence. The genuine fear of the unknown.

    Yet, hints are being shown there and then throughout the film about his past. The six bullet scar wound on his back. His masterful gunslinging. The white dog collar and his knowledge of the law.

    No flashbacks. No backstory.

    WHO IS HE? HE IS THE PREACHER. BUT WHO IS HE? He knows the law, it pisses the Baron off. He knows who Marshall Stockburn is but he is not saying so. He even knows how much is it to hire Stockburn and his 6 Deputies!

    He also kept an 1858 Remington, a leather holster with a stack of bullets hidden in a deposit box. Again, he knows how to shoot for sure. He shows little Josh Lahood the way when he was about to rape Megan.

    And the manner how he handled the 6 Deputies and Stockburn himself in the finale. Also, the six shots he gave Stockburn are in the same way as the scar wound he got on his back. Even with all these hints, who he is?

    Stockburn recognized him at the end. It might have been him who put the six rounds on the Preacher back then.

    When asked by the Baron, he said, "Sounds like a man I once knew."

    The Baron then replies, "Might be. He recognized your name". Stockburn looks at the Baron. Shocked.

    "Couldn't be. The man I'm thinking about is dead" says Stockburn.

    The Preacher might have been once a Marshall himself (with the skill with guns and wits) He might have been fighting the corrupt ones (including Stockburn) which eventually almost cost him his life. He apparently survived the ordeal and become a Christian priest.

    Why he ended up wandering the land to the point he encountered Hull being beaten in the town? Don’t know. But looking at it from other perspectives might give us some hints.

    THE AMERICAN MONOMYTH

    His presence is mythical. Especially with the timing after Megan's prayer for a miracle. Adding to it is his visual relevance to the Biblical verse about one of the Four Horseman of the Apocalypse.

    It is the embodiment and a revelation of a prayer coming true.

    Although my theory about him being a Marshall, this aspect of mysticism takes the Preacher character up a few levels above a normal western hero archetype.

    It is the dog collar that he wears which has earned him the title the Preacher. Megan's mother Sarah has asked him many times but he is somewhat reluctant to answer. Or he simply could not remember. Hence might be one of the reasons why he is lost and wandering around the snowy mountains.

    Or according to Robert Jewett, The American Monomyth, 1977,

    “In the American monomyth, the hero is an outsider who comes into a once-perfect community in peril (the “violated Eden”) to confront the evils that have caused trouble. The hero eschews such things as joining the community, standing apart from them to better keep them safe, in a manner that could best be described as vigilantism. Once the evil has been vanquished, the hero either allows himself to absorb into the community (through such means as moving in, marrying, etc.), or he moves on to the next violated Eden.”

    THE LORD WORKS IN MYSTERIOUS WAYS

    That is the line he said after he managed to deal with the giant Club. The giant scares him by sledgehammering the huge rock and splitting it into two before the Preacher knocks his nose and balls.

    The miracle here is that they didn't have to hammer to huge rock anymore. And they soon found their first golden nugget from it the next day.

    The same can be said about the timing of the Preacher's arrival. A miracle. Need no further explanation.

    Being a Christian preacher also has somehow earned him a Christ-like stature. Being a savior of the needy in most of the part when it comes to the villagers. For Megan, he is the answer to her prayers for an act of revenge. For Sarah, it is the answer to her long-lost desire for love. For Hull, it is a mentor figure to teach him the right way to lead. For the people of LaHood, he is hoping to fight against oppression by the people of the Baron over their gold mine and livelihood.

    But for others, especially Stockburn, he is just bad news. He admits to the Baron that he might have known someone like the Preacher but he is sure that he is already dead. Even though it might have been the Preacher coming to town to settle the score, metaphorically, Stockburn might have also recognized his own death coming his way.

    Which suits the Bible first on his second intro,

    "And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death,"

    Also, the fear in Stockburn's eyes knowing who it is he is facing. "You". Twice. And halted upon drawing his gun (not really typical for a Marshall). But it is Death. No delaying that. The Lord works in mysterious ways.

    RESURRECTION

    pale3.jpg

    Death and Ressurection in one frame

    Another hero archetype characteristic that is typical in almost any religion is the stage where they got resurrected. Jesus got it. Islam got it and also the ancient Persian, just to name a few.

    In film we have hero characters like Neo in the Matrix who got resurrected after being shot by Agent Smith, just to transcend to a higher level of existence.

    Like Jesus Christ.

    Also how Superman after his death back in 1994, was been resurrected, completing the Christ-like biblical journey.

    Like the Preacher.

    The Preacher might have been proclaimed dead by Stockburn, but apparently has been religiously resurrected and got himself into Christianity. Hence the quote shared earlier from Joseph Campbell.

    "The hero’s death and resurrection is a model for the casting off of the old life and moving into the new."

    195121750_10159723075876042_6654235992174620904_n.jpg

    Neo died and got ressurected and transcended into a heigher existence

    HERO WITH A THOUSAND FACES IN THEIR OWN JOURNEYS.

    The Preacher is not the only hero in this story. Further referring to Joseph Campbell's idea of a hero with a thousand faces, it is actually can be applied to all of the good characters in this film. Each is the hero in their journey.

    The most appealing example is Hull as the leader of his community. It is him who made the trip alone to the town to buy supplies on debt. and risk facing the LaHood's men. He then decided to stay and risk the coming of Stockburn and his Deputies if they refuse to take the bribe offer. He also took the long walk back to town to help the Preacher and eventually saved him from the Baron's rifle.

    Sarah's hero journey is her plight to just survive and move on as a mother, and soon wife to Hull. Young Megan's journey is she is learning about love. The villager's journey is to be united and fight together.

    As Christ-like as the Preacher is, the character has encountered few instances that show he is merely human. The giant, Club, saved him from getting shot by Josh. And as said earlier, Hull saved him from Baron.

    Also, his need for love in that scene with Sarah. The next morning Hull gave him the look and mock the rifle at him. The Preacher managed to make a quick escape.

    All in all, we are all the hero in our journey. Especially at times like this. We need to be the miracle.

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post
  3. Pale rider@pocket-toy3128d

    IMG_20171204_165328_541.jpg

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post
  4. 📽 PALE RIDER [Clint Eastwood, 1985] - Movie review by Mandibil@mandibil3489d

    The Clint himself directs this classic western plot, largely in the spaghetti western style, but with a more introvert feel. The nameless avenger is a character that nobody can portray better that Clint himself and despite the undercurrent of religion and mysticism in this case, I cannot but be attracted to it.

    After a community of goldpanning, prospector families are attacked by a larger, competing gold digging corporation run by a LaHood in the neighborhood, a young girl in one of the attacked families begs for a miracle to come by and save them. Then the nameless, pale rider (Clint Eastwood) comes to town and helps her father defeat a gang of thugs also associated and is invited to stay at their their humble lodgings.

    At first they fear him for his ability to wield violence, though in the defense of their defenseless master of the house Hull (Michael Moriarty), but when he flashes a preacher collar and fine manners at the dinner table, their attitude quickly changes to awe and for the females, also a certain sexual attraction.

    Hull is working on a big boulder blocking the nearby stream and when the preacher helps him working on it it soon makes the whole community come together in a reinvigorated form, because of the preachers confidence and stout ethics.

    While the daughter gets more and more attracted to the preacher, the conflict escalates between the community and the LaHood group. Rumours tell that he has sent for a "sherif" of ill repute, who have a gang of deputies, that will be willing to reinstate "law and order" in the canyon. But the preacher has managed to raise the community´s heroic feelings and made them reject LaHoods offer to buy them out of their lots.

    As the conflict comes towards a showdown, the preacher disappears and their previous heroic stance takes a bit of a blow. What they are not aware of is that, the preacher has gone to town to retrieve his gun. As have been previously indicated, he has a past as a hired gun of some kind and he now changes his personality once again to this form to meet the approaching gang of deputies, headed by a man called Stockburn.

    He manages to rescue the daughter from being raped by the LaHood gang and his son, and dragging Hull along for the showdown, just popping down to blow up the whole mining rig of their competition, before heading into town. Stockburn have already showed his psychopatic side, when he protects LaHood from a drunk and angry goldpanner, who struck on a huge nugget of gold and wants to laugh at LaHood, by shooting him full of holes.

    The Preacher takes out the deputies one at a time and at the final showdown Stockburn realizes who he is facing when he yells "Youuuuu ...!!" indicating they have a history "together" of some kind. When all the bad guys are wiped from the town, he rides of into the horizon and is never seen again.

    The religious and slightly mystic undertones are not that strong and I can easily forgive them. It is clearly a film made when Eastwood did not have the skill and experience as a director that would later result in Oscar winners. The opening sequence with the approaching and attacking LaHood gang is not impressive and feels very amateurish. But at least it is the only part that really stinks. The rest does hang fairly well together all though I would personally have loved some more character development and a bit more information about the nameless man and what he came from

    The cinematography is generally ok, although not impressive. Only at a few instances it feels bold and daring but mostly it just tells the story and plot as it is supposed to. The scene where the deputies stand on the stairs and the prospector stands alone, with only his trembling legs in view is great. Some scenes feel a bit to dark and a few scenes feels unrehearsed and rushed. But the overall theme of revenge is quite clear and the whole frame is carved out in a simple and, in a good way, a predictable shape.

    I like a simple and straightforward plot in a western and the stoneface nameless rider is always cool and likable. it appeals to the masculine bravery of taking your own destiny into your own hands and doing the right thing for yourself, your family and your community. It is not as much about praying for someone to come rescue you, which you might think. That is also a fantasy in any case.

    Rating: 7/10

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post