scrobble.life
← Back

Title · no scrobbles indexed yet

Simulant

The first scrobble for this title is still propagating, but a community review is already indexed below.

Reviews

Longform community posts about this title

[Movie review] [Eng | Esp] Simulant | Artificial intelligence has evolved too much@jrjaime1026d
Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post

Comments

No comments yet — be the first.

2 more reviews

  1. 'Simulant' by April Mullen Review: Blade Runner without the soul@namiks1134d

    vlcsnap-2023-05-22-01h07m20s356.png

    I came across Simulant about a week or two ago around its release, initially seeing a few posts online on what a disappointment it was; most of the negativity seeming to stem more towards actor Simu Liu, who luckily burst into fame with some superhero casting that wasn't met all that well with audiences. I don't think it's fair to really throw hate at an actor due to any specific role they've played, whether it's good or bad or just not your thing. I do have actors I prefer and think don't hold as much talent as others; and I do think that actor Simu Liu is mostly miscast, rather than just a bad performer. And he's certainly not alone in this as Hollywood eyes up its younger performers and tests the waters for the new era of "A List" actors. There's a lot of actors sort of thrown around in a variety of genres they just don't really suit. I noticed this with the Dungeons & Dragons film that recently flopped, for example.

    While Liu doesn't seem like someone that screams cyberpunk genre, his performance here in Simulant isn't that bad. In fact, Simulant itself isn't a terrible film. It just seems, similar to the general theme so far, a bit out of place. Thrown together in the slow revival of science fiction films as concepts such as artificial intelligence grow common in the public eye. A few of which I have noticed being suddenly released as of late. Low budget, AI themed, and tackling the blatant question of what it means to be alive. To no surprise, these ideas can only stretch so far, and it's a difficult genre to enter without just repeating that of which has already been said. The result to this is these science fiction films sprinkle in some other ideas that may or may not really work, often pulling influence from this aforementioned works that came before.

    To refer to Simulant as Blade Runner without the soul is to admit I open up that big door to the assumption that everything science fiction is just copying Blade Runner because "Well, it's just the best." Don't get me wrong, there's a lot of cyberpunk films that do manage to do their own things and compete with it; Simulant's problem is it effectively copies Blade Runner in many ways. You'll get an idea of just how much as the review goes on. And, of course, you should expect spoilers. But you probably weren't going to watch this anyway.

    Simulant

    vlcsnap-2023-05-22-00h51m14s708.png

    Sam Worthington seems to be appearing a bit more suddenly in these lower budget films, some decent, some bad. This is completely unrelated to anything major here in the review, but it's nice to see he's still getting roles and trying different ideas out. He's a decent actor, and his performances are never an issue. The same can be said for Robbie Amell, who seems mostly ignored by Hollywood and still roaming around lower budget films choosing mostly action and science fiction flicks. While I don't have any issues with their performances, there is some weakness in the script which makes their characters a bit dull. This is a script that drags on for far too long and really tries to stretch out this idea that we already full understand. Simulants are just Replicants from Blade Runner. Individuals rebuilt after death to look and act like the deceased. These simulants are growing more intelligent, leading to fears of them gaining full consciousness and becoming a threat. Here comes the strong reliance on Blade Runner! Simulant's main narrative is that a bounty hunter is hired to destroy these simulants before it's too late (Deckard) as the film, and not-Deckard struggle to come to terms with whether they're really taking a life or not. With the returning question on what life is coming into play far too often.

    To no surprise we get the perspectives of these simulants that believe they are alive and hold memories. Displaying emotional attachment to them and very much displaying the idea that they aren't different at all from the deceased they're copying. It feels like the film sticks around a bit too much as it reminds us of all of this over and over, especially with little elements of world building which just aren't that immersive due to budget reasons. Simulant, being a film about AI, feels the need to display a very present environment, with minor changes like special effects drones flying around or those annoying floating touchscreens lazy science fiction absolutely loves using to depict anything remotely futuristic. Not to forget the hologram ads in the sky above buildings which spout some sort of advertisement or not-so-subtle reference to something to come later on. Either some product or corporation that holds some significance to the plot. Simulant's world building is by far the most boring aspect of the film, just completely soulless and stuck to generic tropes.

    Though, for a film with a low budget, visually Simulant isn't that bad at all! I noticed some interesting perspectives that made the film a bit creative in parts. Wide angle lenses and a very filmic look, met with immersive editing techniques when necessary. The camera movements and lighting certainly don't scream low budget and time constraints. I was quite surprised to see such quality despite the story just being utterly lacking; especially when the editor weirdly chose to add in some clearly Blade Runner music that is absolutely a knock-off Vangelis composition. Almost synth but without any really emotion or rhythm to it. It would spring up out of nowhere when it wasn't needed to set the tone, and being used so much, it was clear that the attempt was to just promote the cyberpunk, science fiction aesthetic we were supposed to be feeling. I didn't feel it though, aside from floating screens and fancy minimalist architecture, everything pretty much seemed very grounded and close to now. Though I understand that budget means shooting locations and time is limited. I'm just glad that it didn't go full generic cyberpunk and throw in red, blue, and pink lights everywhere.

    Perhaps some of this is again down to the casting, to which the actors themselves just don't suit this environment. They aren't that believable therefore immersion is highly difficult to feel. Nobody seems to fit into this world, which only makes you question just what else really does. Simulant unfortunately just falls victim to the science fiction and futurist curse like many before it. Not managing to stand out at all in narrative or visuals. Just another story that'll end up buried in the sea of others, not garnering any additional influence within the genre nor being memorable. It's not terrible, though. It just doesn't have anything new to share.

    Join the Movies and TV Shows Community Discord.

    Follow our curation trail!

    Follow me over on Twitter!

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post
  2. Simulant | Movie Review 🎥@josehany1150d

    Today I want to talk a little bit about this movie that I saw today and I feel like I'll keep it pretty brief.

    We are going to start with the review that HBOMAX presents us because it is a film on this platform. Then we have that, after the death of her husband, Evan, Faye decides to transfer his consciousness to an android, but soon realizes that artificial intelligence is not capable of replacing her true love and ends up in an unexpected chase plot.

    Hoy quiero hablar un poco de esta película que ví hoy y siento que seré bastante breve.

    Vamos a empezar con la reseña que nos presenta HBOMAX porque es una película de esta plataforma. Entonces tenemos que, tras la muerte de su marido, Evan, Faye decide transferir su conciencia a un androide, pero pronto se da cuenta de que la inteligencia artificial no es capaz de sustituir a su verdadero amor y termina en una inesperada trama de persecución.


    500ab2d2-ab0f-4313-bfd3-79c813c0e7e2.png

    Source

    From this review we understand that it is going to be an action and science fiction movie or at least that's what you get the idea of, well that's what I thought.

    We started watching Evan's accident and in fact that scene is so confusing to me, at least for me it is not so clear that I thought the accident had happened to Feya (his wife) then the next scene we see is that this couple is normally living together but the interaction is not the same and it shows... And beyond that we see that Evan says that he is having nightmares about that accident.

    Por esta reseña entendemos que se va a tratar de una película de acción y de ciencia ficción o al menos de eso te haces la idea, bueno es lo que yo pensé.

    Empezamos viendo el accidente de Evan y de hecho se me hace tan confusa esa escena, al menos para mí no queda tan clara que pensaba que el accidente había Sido de feya (su esposa) luego la siguiente escena que vemos es que esta pareja está normalmente conviviendo juntos pero la interacción no es la misma y se nota... Y más allá de eso vemos que Evan dice que está teniendo pesadillas sobre aquel accidente.


    Evan-Faye_NightPool_1df2765f-ecc4-ed11-a9e5-d4b7dc424a90.jpg

    Source

    After a while we found out that Evans is really a Simulant, that is to say, a robot with a form of consciousness pierced by the thoughts of Evan himself, to be and remember the things that Evan remembered... In fact, he himself did not know that he was a Simulant until Feya confesses to him.

    Al rato nos enteramos que realmente Evans es un Simulant, es decir un robot con una forma de conciencia traspasada por los pensamientos del mismo Evan, para ser y recordar las cosas que Evan recordaba... De hecho, el mismo no sabía que era un Simulant hasta que Feya se lo confiesa.


    simulant-e1678391604639.jpg Source

    Feya begins to feel strange with him and at one point she decides that she wants to get rid of him, because she is confused she thinks that part of her husband is inside the Simulant but at the same time she knows that it is a robot. Later she calls someone to check her Simulant and later this person tells her that everything is fine, and that if she wishes he has a place where they can both stay (referring to Feya and Evan).

    Feya empieza a sentirse extraña con él y en un punto decide que quiere deshacerse de él, porque está confundida piensa que parte de su esposo está dentro del Simulant pero a la vez sabe que es un robot. Más adelante ella llama a alguien para que revise su Simulant y este le dice que todo está bien, y que si desea él tiene un lugar donde puedan hospedarse ambos (se refiere a Feya y Evan).


    CapsuleRoom3_{393a4bd5-f9c4-ed11-a9e5-d4b7dc424a90}.jpg Source

    Feya attends the place but to take Evan, and she planned to leave him there for a month and have time to think but what she really wanted to do was get rid of him. The same person who went to Feya's house to check on him tells him that he is a Simulant and that he can help free him by removing restrictions and commands, and he does so to the point where he is a totally independent robot, he doesn't obey anyone... And from there everything is a bit more confusing and loses a bit of meaning.

    Feya asiste al lugar pero para llevar a Evan, y planeaba dejarlo ahí un mes y tener tiempo para pensar pero lo que realmente quería hacer era deshacerse de él. La misma persona que fue a la casa de Feya a revisarlo le dice que él es un Simulant y que puede ayudar a liberarlo quitarle restricciones y comandos, y así hace hasta el punto en que es un robot totalmente independiente, no obedece a nadie ... Y a partir de ahí todo es un poco más confuso y pierde un poco el sentido.


    Casey_Hack1_{0d245bfa-ebc4-ed11-a9e5-d4b7dc424a90}.jpg Source

    To be honest, I don't like this movie, I could consider it a bad movie. I didn't understand what the main point was, everything is laid out in a very vague way, they never finish developing the scenes, everything is half done, I honestly felt that I needed more information for everything to make sense and be in order. It does not inspire you to anything and totally lacks originality.

    Honestly it was all very vague, I didn't like it, just as I also share the good things, it is necessary to share the not so good ones

    Para ser honesta, no me gusta esta película, yo podría considerarla una mala película. No entendí cuál fue el punto principal, todo está planteado de una forma muy vaga, nunca terminan de desarrollar las escenas, todo queda como a medias, honestamente sentí que necesitaba más información para que todo tuviera sentido y estuviera en orden. No te inspira a nada y carece totalmente de originalidad.

    Honestamente todo fue muy vago, no me gustó, así como también comparto las cosas buenas, es necesario compartir las que no son tan buenas.


    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post