scrobble.life
Movies & TV Shows

Television Review: Forced Perspective (Fringe, S4x10, 2012)

(source:tmdb.org)

Forced Perspective (S04E10)

Airdate: 27 January 2012 Written by: Ethan Gross Directed by: David Solomon Running Time: 43 minutes

Certain episodes of Fringe would have landed far better had they been broadcast early in the series’ run. These are, almost without exception, the “mystery of the week” procedurals — the ones in which a strange case is opened, investigated and closed inside forty-four minutes, with the mythology confined to a couple of muttered exchanges at either end. In the first season such instalments had a function: they established the world, the team and the tone, and they taught the audience the grammar of the show. By the fourth season, even when the machinery is assembled competently, they tend to sit in the schedule like roadblocks on the long trudge towards resolution. Forced Perspective is one of these, and it is all the more frustrating for displaying talents and resources that would have been far better deployed elsewhere.

The case itself does at least attempt a thematic connection to the prophetic warning September handed Olivia at the close of Back Where You’ve Never Been a fortnight earlier. That warning hangs over the episode: Olivia is visibly rattled, and Broyles is concerned enough about her wellbeing to start restricting what she is allowed to do in the field. It is a reasonable dramatic use of the cliffhanger, though it never quite becomes more than background noise once the plot gets going.

What the plot gets going with is a young girl, Emily Mallum (Alexis Raich), who suffers from headaches and responds to them by drawing. She hands one such drawing to a stranger, Robert Englehart (Patrick Spencer), shortly before the same man is impaled by a girder falling from a nearby construction site — an event depicted in the sketch. Fringe Division is called in and identifies Emily quickly enough, arriving at her home to find her father Jim (Currie Graham) entirely unsurprised by any of it. The family has moved constantly, Jim explains, because he is afraid Emily will be taken by Massive Dynamic and by whatever other interested parties might wish to experiment on her abilities. He uses his parental authority to obstruct the investigation at every turn. Olivia sympathises more than she lets on, having been a subject of comparable experimentation herself, and she takes the matter up with Nina Sharp — only to be disappointed when Nina admits that Massive Dynamic was, indeed, interested in the girl.

The conversation is interrupted by Emily, who wants a word with Olivia alone. She has had a vision of a man she met on a bus (Jonathan Walker) who will die alongside a great many other people, and her drawing offers no clue as to how or when. She is brought to Walter’s lab, where Walter theorises that her brain is picking up vibrations from traumatic events rippling backwards through time. With Jim’s grudging approval, he puts her under hypnosis. The man is identified as Albert Duncan, embittered by the loss of a custody battle to the point of planting an explosive device intended to take out both himself and the judge. The FBI and Fringe Division arrive in the nick of time, Duncan is prevented from triggering the bomb, and Olivia talks him into surrendering quietly.

The triumph is immediately soured. Emily suffers a fatal stroke, brought on by the very condition that gave her the gift, an event she had predicted in one of her own drawings and which duly plays out on a bench by the lake, with her father and Olivia watching. Elsewhere, Peter attempts to explain the Observers of his own timeline to an Olivia who has never heard of them. The episode closes with Nina visiting Olivia in a maternal capacity while, outside, one of the Observers watches.

Forced Perspective is a good episode, and much of the credit belongs to Ethan Gross’s script, which wrings the best possible result out of a procedural premise only flimsily attached to the series’ mythology. It gives us another tragic figure, and the tragedy stings harder because it happens to people who can reasonably be called good: Emily is an innocent victim in the purest sense, and even her overprotective father does the right thing in the end. Yet, as with so many of these storylines, the resolution is melodramatic in a way that guarantees the writers of later episodes will not have to complicate an already convoluted overarching plot with any new recurring appearances. Emily dies, the case closes, the file goes in a drawer.

The episode is greatly aided by a strong performance from Alexis Raich, a prolific child actress for whom the role of Emily has, sadly, represented the peak of her career — at least so far. She carries the hour with a solemnity that never tips into precocity, and she makes the character’s loneliness legible without announcing it.

David Solomon, a veteran of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, directs with real assurance, most notably in the sequence that reconstructs the explosion from Emily’s vision using bullet time. It is arguably one of the most striking images Fringe ever produced, certainly in its later stages, and it briefly makes the whole enterprise feel more significant than its plot deserves.

That, in the end, is the trouble. The attempts to tie the episode into the wider arc feel like narrative checkmarks rather than organic content — Olivia’s unease, Peter’s exposition, the watcher at the window — dutiful boxes ticked so that the episode can claim relevance to a story it otherwise ignores. It is well made, well acted and, at moments, genuinely moving. It is also a detour, and by this point in the season detours cost more than they used to.

RATING: 6/10 (++)

IMDb link

Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/ InLeo blog @drax.leo Substack https://draxster.substack.com

LeoDex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax 1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e

BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7 BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk8

Comments

No comments yet — be the first.