Films may have many qualities, and one of such qualities can be prophetic dimension. The best known example of prophetic film is Alexander Nevsky, shot in Soviet Union only few years before the history conspired to create its real life remake. But the most talked about case of film-makers predicting future is The Siege, 1998 action thriller directed by Edward Zwick.
The plot begins when US forces, following terrorist attacks against American military installations, manage to capture Sheikh Achmed Bin Talal (played by Ahmed Bin Larby), militant religious leader from Iraq. Few months later, Anthony Hubbard (played by Denzel Washington), FBI agent in charge of counterterrorism operations in New York, receives warning that the city could become target of Islamist terrorists. Hubbard begins investigation and trail leads to Ellie Kraft (played by Annette Benning), CIA agent who refuses to cooperate with FBI in order not to expose her valuable contacts in Arab world. She changes her mind after the first bombs create carnage in New York and later helps Hubbard in breaking terrorist cells. Their efforts to prevent further bombings fail and President, pressed by public opinion and frustrated by law enforcement's inability to stop the terrorists, introduces martial law and sends military under General Deveraux (played by Bruce Willis) to deal with the problem. Deveraux's solution to the problem is simple - round up all of New York's Arabs and Muslims and use torture them into giving up terrorists and their sympathisers. Hubbard is outraged with this blatant breech of constitutional liberties and that leads to conflict with Deveraux.
Many characters, situations and images from The Siege feature frightening similarity with the events that happened only few years after the premiere - thousands of New Yorkers die because of terrorist attack, US government responds with military force and curbs many rights while counter-terrorism campaign degenerates into torture and abuse. Even film's scenes featuring 1990s standards of Hollywood nudity in R-rated films - where males are allowed to disrobe, while females aren't - have unpleasant resemblance with some of the current events. Needless to say, many of the issues addressed in this film are relevant today. The film shows how modern nations are vulnerable to terrorism and how their response to this grave threat can degenerate in full scale abuse of power. The Siege also addressed another issue, which had been previously ignored or brushed aside in Hollywood films - position of Arabs and Muslims in American society and how this minority can find itself in the very same situation in which Catholics, Irish, blacks, Jews, Italians, Germans and Japanese were in various traumatic periods of American history.
Zwick's approach to those issues in many ways reflects sentiments of leftist and liberal Hollywood. While the film admits that some American Muslims and American Arabs can become terrorists and cause great pain and misery to their fellow citizens, The Siege tries very hard to draw sharp distinction between terrorists who are insignificant minority and overwhelming majority who are decent people whose patriotism and civic values can't be questioned. Film's script underlines this by having Lebanese Shiite as Hubbard's partner (who, ironically, sees his own son being subjected to interment by the his government). The Siege goes even further from usual "political correctness" of Hollywood by showing that US government has its own share of responsibility for the problem. Terrorist organisation in the film was once funded and aided by US government (which is another striking parallel with real life events) and it could be even argued that the terrorists have legitimate grievances. In the second part of the film US government itself becomes part of the problem, or at least its segment associated with the right-wing political ideas and military-industrial complex.
All this could have served as an excellent basis for serious political drama, but Zwick found itself constrained by Hollywood genre conventions of action thriller. His script co-written with Menno Meyjes and Lawrence Wright added to the confusion, especially in the characterisation. Probably the worst example comes in the form of General Deveraux - at the very beginning of the film he is presented as efficient, professional and honourable soldier only to appear as simplistic brute at the film's end. The least convincing aspect of the script is suggestion that of all US government agencies FBI is most qualified to solve terrorism problems - in the film Hubbard not only manages to put the stop on bombing campaign, but also shows ability to successfully confront US military. In those scenes The Siege looks laughable compared to the real life.
On the other hand, Zwick knows how to direct few interesting action scenes and the acting is generally very good. Denzel Washington is always dependable in the role of intellectual and righteous protagonist, while Tony Shalhoub is very good as his partner. Annette Benning, on the other hand, couldn't do much with her thankless role while Bruce Willis, just like in The Jackal, showed how role of villains weren't his forte.
Despite its authors' good intentions and its prophetic quality, The Siege is a deeply flawed film. Just like the events it foretold, this film represents something audience wouldn't like to be reminded of.
RATING: 4/10 (+)
(Note: The text in its original form was posted in Usenet newsgroup rec.arts.films.reviews on May 26th 2004)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/ Cent profile https://beta.cent.co/@drax Minds profile https://www.minds.com/drax_rp_nc Uptrennd profile https://www.uptrennd.com/user/MTYzNA
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7



