scrobble.life
← Back

Title · no scrobbles indexed yet

Memories of Murder

The first scrobble for this title is still propagating, but a community review is already indexed below.

Reviews

Longform community posts about this title

Film Review: Memories of Murder (2003)@drax104d
Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post

Comments

No comments yet — be the first.

3 more reviews

  1. Memories of murder - based on a true story, directed by Bong Joon-ho: a great thriller movie.@aurzeq1564d

    capture.png

    Source

    Plot

    1986, South Korea. The discovery of a barbarically raped girl's body in a tiny provincial town prompts an investigation by the inept local police, who are more interested in finding a scapegoat than the true perpetrator. Another victim is discovered a short time later, and an inspector from Seoul arrives to assist in the investigation and throw light on the mystery.

    Why you should watch it?

    • The characters: Two investigators with starkly opposing styles of investigation. The first is Park Du-man, a regime slave who is uninterested in the truth and willing to falsify evidence in order to fast seal the case. A detective whose investigative style is staring into a person's eyes as if it were a superpower to determine if he is lying or telling the truth. Instead, Seo Tae-Yun, a young and ambitious investigator fresh from profiling school, arrives from Seoul to try to rationalize the case by studying the elements and looking for similar denominators across the many murders. He is not a charming and brilliant Sherlock Holmes, but a regular and human investigator who is used to research and rationality. The conflict between logic and impulsiveness, between conjectures and verifiable facts, is intense, and it leads to a confrontation between two detectives who are not cooperating in the hunt for the serial killer who going to strike.

    aaaabbkszp6edcuuc15ci_gesjaamwtgwmuqvrapbjgozdzymopijhy2z4_lp08htm1xwrdmkl6_gd6c1foipxnllgdl1g9b.jpg

    Source
    • A fake-truth: The investigative violence has become so intense that it has created a paradox. The suspects' statements are no longer valid since they are slavish repetitions of the truths that the detectives prefer to hear. As a result, nothing has any meaning anymore, and it's difficult to tell the difference between aspects of actual confession and others of forced identification in the quest to end the suffering. The authority constructs its false success, carefully mounts it, and even brags about it. Without a specific investigative corps, forensics, or the ability to apply DNA testing, the investigation is conducted carelessly. An inquiry marked by the use of torture during interrogations is guided by gossip, prejudice, and improbable extrasensory powers. The expert detective is the one who can recognize a tile of truth in the mosaic of fakes in this world confounded by armed force. In a circumstance that is gray and inaccessible to people seeking actual understanding, there is a spark of authenticity. The spectator falls prey to the characters' utilitarian logic and occasionally believes he has discovered the guilty alongside them. The one with the unattractive face, the one who masturbates in the woods, the one who requests a song on the radio. They're the shattered crutches of an absurd reasoning that believes it can track down the killer by walking around the countryside.

    rl3kyoi3zuozldypqyl9pqxsvaor2y_original.jpg

    Source
    • The ability of Bong Joon-Ho:The tone of the picture, as well as the characters' personalities, shifts. At first, the investigators' mumbling is tinged with a dark sense of humour. Their ineptness is absurd and crazy, especially as seen through the eyes of Seo, the outsider. Bong Joon-ho, on the other hand, gradually guides his work into darker and more sad waters. In the end, not all of the victims are faceless, and there is at least one sequence (seen from the killer's point of view as he selects which of the two ladies to attack) when the tension reaches thriller levels. The seamless, unerring way the Korean filmmaker guides the narrative through swings in tone demonstrates his directorial skills.

    qu9toskhavol8kdumnfvbtvgxyy2zs.jpg

    Source
    • The normality of life: The protagonists' backgrounds are hidden so that the key element is highlighted: normality. No character represents the hero or the anti-hero; none of them has a particular charisma that could distinguish them. The normality of provincial life, the normality of those who hold power, the normality of people outside that environment, the normality of perversion, and the normality of the murderer's face. Murder is the only abnormal ingredient that, in a fully ordinary climate, among ordinary people, ends up becoming part of the everyday, in the routine of people who distrust the police more than their neighbors. The word "evil" itself becomes banal.

    memories_of_murder_song_1_.jpg

    Source

    Conclusion

    Memories of Murder is a slow-paced film that seems more like a noir than a thriller due to its reliance on hints and atmospheres. The slow descent of its characters into infatuation with the murderer, as well as the open and unfinished finale, foreshadows another cornerstone of the serial-killer genre, David Fincher's Zodiac (although here the finale is more philosophical and less unexpected in my opinion, and provides an overview of the idea the director has of life). On top of this,it is also based on a true story, which makes it even more fascinating. In all regards, this is a must-watch movie, that has a lot of perks and almost any defects.

    Rating

    My personal vote is:

    9.0/10


    If you enjoyed the post, please leave an upvote and/or a comment, and feel free to follow me (at the link below) if you want to see my next movie review.

    ➡️ hive.blog/@aurzeq ⬅️

    fIRMA_hIVE.png

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post
  2. Memories of a murder (Película): un asesino serial bajo el ojo de Bong Joon-Ho@cristiancaicedo2237d

    Antes de arrasar en los Oscars y en otras galas de premios con su película Parasite; antes de la original y directa Okja, antes de la adaptación de ciencia ficción con Chris Evans Snowpiercer y antes de la dramática cinta Mother cuya reseña puedes leer aquí, el Director de Cine Surcoreano Bong Joon-ho nos legó esta película llamada Salinui chueok (Memories of Murder), en español Memorias de un asesinato.

    Este fue apenas el segundo largometraje de Bong Joon-Ho, después de Barking dogs never bite y ya demostraba el talento que lo llevó por el camino del éxito. La película es un thriller policíaco en toda regla, basado en hechos reales. Ambientada en su país natal en la década de los ochenta, la historia inicia con una joven que aparece brutalmente violada y asesinada. Las marcas en el cuerpo y algunas disposiciones alrededor del asesinato llaman la atención de la policía, sobre todo cuando poco tiempo después, se producen otros casos similares. Los cuerpos de seguridad saben que se encuentran entonces tras la pista de un violador y asesino en serie que caza a sus víctimas según ciertas características y para capturarlo ponen a cargo al detective de la policía local Park Doo-man y a un detective de la policía de Seúl, la capital, Seo Tae-yoon, que ha solicitado ser asignado al caso.

    Los fanáticos del género amarán esta película. Tenemos un asesino en serie que es también un violador y que reacciona a ciertos fetiches muy particulares, lo que ayudaría en teoría a reducir la cantidad de sospechosos; tenemos un detective local con años de experiencia, secundado por uno más joven, capitalino, que no sabe cómo se llevan las cosas en las provincias y ello le genera diferencias con sus semejantes; tenemos la investigación propiamente dicha, las escenas del crimen, las pistas, las teorías, el análisis de mapas, locaciones, las horas de los ataques, las posibles huellas dejadas por el perpetrador, todo acercando más y más a los policías hasta la identidad del sospechoso; todo lo que necesita una buena historia policíaca para atrapar al espectador, está presente en la trama.

    Pero también tiene el sello de su Director. El abuso policial retratado en otras de sus películas, ya está presente en esta, incluido ese señalamiento de una persona con discapacidad como autor de un crimen muy grave, rasgo que comparte esta cinta con Mother, una obra maestra del surcoreano. El clasismo, la violencia, la vida de los menos favorecidos, rasgos que marcarían otras de sus historias, también se hallan en esta. Si bien otros de sus films tienen algo (o mucho) de suspenso y siguen una estructura de thriller, ninguna lo hace en un sentido más puro que esta persecución de un asesino en serie escurridizo, al más puro estilo de Zodiac, la famosa película de David Fincher, una producción con la que Memories of a murder comparte más de un punto.

    La película se presentó en diversos festivales internacionales durante el año de su estreno, entre ellos el Festival de San Sebastián, donde fue galardonada con el premio FIPRESCI (decidido por más de 350 profesionales de todo el mundo de entre la producción cinematográfica internacional), el premio Nuevos Directores y la Concha de Plata al mejor director, lo que no es poca cosa para un Director que apenas realizaba su segundo largometraje. Cuando busqué esta cinta para verla me topé con otra cinta del mismo país llamada en inglés Memoir of a murderer, cuya traducción al español puede confundir a quienes quieran ver una u otra. Por fortuna, esa otra, de 2017, también es buena, pero si le están siguiendo la pista a Bong Joon-Ho, tengan cuidado de ver la correcta. Si les gustan las cintas tipo Prisoners, Zodiac, Gone Girl, les va a gustar esta intensa búsqueda policial que, en mi opinión, merece un 8/10 por la fotografía, el guión, las actuaciones, pero sobre todo por la calidad de su dirección, materia en la que Bong Joon-Ho nunca ha quedado a deber.

    Reseñado por @cristiancaicedo

    Otros posts que pueden interesarte:

    Fotografía: Richie's [ESP-ENG]

    |

    --- | ---

    The half of it (Película): identidad y audacia

    |

    Artequín: un museo para los más pequeños

    |
    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post
  3. Memories of Murder Review: South Korea's Haunting Past@namiks3270d

    Memories of Murder.jpg

    There are few instances in which films based on true events strongly follow their original tales; often enough, such instances are only loosely following the truth, using inspiration and only minor events.

    Memories of Murder doesn't appear to be that at all, it's a film that shows the heartbreaking loss of life and the struggles of those who, for many years, tried their very best to catch the person responsible. This is South Korea's way of using film to tell the world of its wounds that cannot heal, and will never understand why those wounds occurred in the first place. It's forever haunted by an unsolved series of murders.

    The events in the film follow the Hwaseong serial murders from September 15, 1986 and April 3, 1991. The victims, all female and of varying ages, were found to have been murdered all in the same way. A total of 21,280 suspects and no sustainable evidence has caused the investigation to remain unsolved to this day. This is South Korea's Zodiac Killer.

    Memories of Murder shows the viewer the struggles of the police, who are growing increasingly attached to the investigation; their time and health becoming affected as it begins to affect them on an emotional level. They want nothing more than to capture the killer and ensure the killer gets the punishment they deserve. The police are thrown in circles, however. Evidence is there, but it just isn't enough to really find the person responsible.

    The biggest touch to the film is by far its ending (don't worry, it's hardly a spoiler given the murders are still unsolved). Our protagonist police officer is walking home from his new job, it's a different career path that he chose after the events of the investigation, he is walking by the location of the first murder; he stops in his steps, looks at the very location in which the victim was found. A young schoolgirl asks him what he is doing, and claims another man once did the same thing he did, although when she asked him, he claimed he was just revisiting the location after doing something there long ago. It's the lead he always needed, but it is too late. The girl says the guy was, well, ordinary. Just like him.

    The final shot shows our protagonist look deep into the camera, his eyes tearing up with the heartbreak of South Korea. He isn't just looking into the camera, but looking at the viewers. One of which may very well be that killer. It's a tragically deep ending that breaks the fourth wall. The killer is still out there. Possibly watching.

    Permalink·Open on PeakD ↗·Linked from existing Hive post